Crossover results (Gold Indian Head Half Eagle) - early birthday present

enzet

I've been collecting certified Gold Indian Head $5 Half Eagles for some time now and recently, I decided to try to cross them over to PCGS for my Registry set and for the reason that I trust PCGS graders more than the other TPG's. Although I have prepared myself for a few downgrades, I'm very happy with the initial result of my submission.

Year FROM TO
1908 NGC AU58 PCGS AU58
1911 NGC MS61 PCGS AU58
1912 NGC MS61 PCGS MS61
1912-S ICG AU58 PCGS AU55
1914-S NGC XF45 PCGS XF45
1915 NGC MS61 PCGS MS61

I'm very glad there's no DNC. Now I just hope the other 2 coins (a 1910 NGC MS61 and a raw 1914-D) will do as well.

My son and I will both celebrate our birthdays tomorrow (yes he was born on my birthday!) and I consider this crossover result an early birthday gift from PCGS.

Cheers!

ricko

Great results - even better that you are pleased. It is a pleasure to open one of these threads and not read a bunch of whining commentary about the graders having a bad night etc. I wish you luck on your other submissions. Cheers, RickO

chucknra

Great results and happy birthday. Just shows you how the TPGs grade differently.

Blackborder

<< <i>Great results and happy birthday. Just shows you how the TPGs grade differently. >>




Looks pretty consistent to me.

lkeigwin

Very nice. Congrats! I hope you're happy with the others.

I'll echo ricko's sentiment too.
Lance.