Which Registry Set Do You Like The Least?

Boey

If you were able to delete a registry set, which one would it be and why?

For me it would be the Peace Dollar Registry Set. This is because I never really cared for the design (was a follow-up to the Morgan Dollar, which can't be beat), and all of the dollar coins I have seen never had any solid strikes or attractive luster. Never really impressed me. Now the Morgans on the other hand....

Sincerely,

Chris

TomB

State Quarters, both proof and mint state.

tradedollarnut

The Louis Eliasberg "Phantom Cameo" proof trade dollar set.

Typetone

I really think every series has interesting features for advanced collectors of the series. So, I would keep them all. But if you really pressed me, I would say goodbye to Sacs. For some reason, I just don't appreciate them. Maybe from all the hype surrounding the Goodacres.

Greg

CarlWohlforth

I'd also get rid of the phantom sets. Sure an article discussing where historic sets might fit would be interesting. However estimated grades just don't belong in the Registry.

Higashiyama

American Eagles. It is tedious looking at all those MS69s.

madmike

<< <i>American Eagles. It is tedious looking at all those MS69s. >>



It's funny that when you actually try to put an MS69 set together those coins seem so incredibly scarce!

Currently only 73 complete MS69 sets are possible (1994 MS69 pop is at 73).

I know some folks don't like them, but it really is a fun set.

Of course I guess I'm biased as they were the first coins I ever collected.

madmike

kieferscoins

The phantom sets. I don't have any sets under their category, but I see how they discourage great collections like tradedollarnuts.

Cameron Kiefer

goose3

The 2 sets above me!(#'s 1 and 2)

cosmicdebris

The abominations DH and company are making of the 1900 and later type sets.

kyleknap

PCGS entering sets that are in other services holder, like the Eliasberg PR Trade set tha TDN mentioned, or the Eliasberg PR gold sets.

Kyle

BigMac

Phantom sets.

danarchy

The one's that they have just dropped roughly half of my coins, and replaced them with state quarters

EVillageProwler

If I were able to delete a set, it would be the Legend Collection of Trade Dollars. Why? 'Cuz it would give someone else a chance to come close... With TDN's set there, no one would even be able to come close.

:-) :-) :-)

EVP

Boey

If the majority of the members here that have registry sets dislike the Phantom Sets, would it help to conduct a poll similar to the others ones going right now? Would it do any good? Would PCGS listen?

Sincerely,

Chris

mdwoods

Curse you Red Baron. I have finally completed a set of Sacs worthy of the registry and now you want to do away with them.
Nay I say, Nay and Nay again. Just kidding, although I wish they would finally all get together and settle the Goodacre issues. Mark

QuickMiata

Get rid of:

#1 State Quarters

#2 Phantom Sets

#3 Phantom Singles in sets