1923 Rainbow Toned Peace Dollar! Opinions and will PCGS grade it?

icsoccer · July 11, 2009 9:05AM

I bought this today, raw. Not a great date, not an especially high grade.
What it does have is color....and luster galore.
The color washes right over the top of the devices, I believe it's good.
I expect that at 50% of the responses may disagree...blast away...lol.

Is the color good and will PCGS grade it? There is a faint line/ scratch/bag mark just under the eye back into
the hair. Noted for accuracy.
Rushed on pics to get them posted...still learning how to photograph color.
Thank You!

anablep · July 11, 2009 9:09AM

Looks beautiful.

Honestly, who cares what PCGS thinks. If you bought it because you love the look of it, then that should be satisfaction enough.

If you're playing the grading game, then you may win this one, but you may lose. In any case, it's still the same coin no matter what the TPG thinks.

Good luck & enjoy it for what it's worth to you.

stinkinlincoln · July 11, 2009 9:11AM

Not sure if PCGS will grade it, but like mentioned, who cares! Thats a great looking Peace regardless of anything else. Normally I wouldnt feel that way, but I like this coin alot.