What grade would this card get

Aric

I am getting together cards for the group submission. I am having problems differentiating between a 6 and 7. It seems like a lot of my stuff falls in this range making it borderline not worth submitting. So what do you think this would grade?

fattymacs

Guessing a 5

bsidegrve

6 oc

iamthegreatcornholio

<< <i>6 oc >>



uh, it's well-within 80/20.

I'd say a 5.5

Dboneesq

IMO, that top left corner by itself would knock it down to the "5" range.

daddymc

I'd also say a 5.

swartz1

6 on a good day...

Aric

Yeah, now that I look at the high res scans, I would agree it probably would not even get a 6. I was trying to do these without a loupe. I ordered one but it hasn't arrived yet. I guess I should take a look at the high res scans of them instead. Looks like I'll be sending in even less submissions than I thought.

Staying with a Vikings theme, what do you think of this one:

Bosox1976

6

daddymc

<< <i>6 >>



Agree. I think that one is a 6 as well.

Aric

What is keeping Tarkenton from a 7?

Would this at least get a 7?

OAKESY25

oj looks like a 7...
maybe 7.5+

tarkenton's bottom corners and centering issues make it a 6

DamageInc

Sad, but I have had 8's with corners like the Tarkenton.......

CDsNuts

6
6
8

sbtrailrider

I think OJ is more like a 7.5 to 9... years in jail, that is!

http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/12/05/oj.simpson.sentencing/index.html

divecchia

The OJ has a shot at a 7 or 8.

Donato

onebamafan

5
5
7

jradke4

<< <i>I am getting together cards for the group submission. I am having problems differentiating between a 6 and 7. It seems like a lot of my stuff falls in this range making it borderline not worth submitting. So what do you think this would grade?



<< <i>

with the corners on that one i would not like to think it would ever be in anything over a 4.5. those are some serious damaged corners. yet you can have great corners but a surface crease that is barely seen and it is automatically a 5.

cwazzy

<< <i>with the corners on that one i would not like to think it would ever be in anything over a 4.5. those are some serious damaged corners. yet you can have great corners but a surface crease that is barely seen and it is automatically a 5. >>



I don't see this grading less than a 5 unless there are a couple of surface wrinkles that don't show up in the scan. And our definition of "serious damaged corners" are obviously different. While they are not sharp enough to grade much higher than a 5 they still aren't that bad IMHO.

RonBurgundy

6,7,7.5.


Or: PSA 6. Chaz.

fiveniner

5,6,7