Would You Support this Registry Idea?

braddick

I think it would be a good idea for PCGS to offer a Sacagawea Registry where the Mint State and the Proof coins are combined into one.

This would include Satin Finish coins. The complete registry would still only be a little over 30 coins (as of 2007). What do you think? A good idea, or not?

Edited to add:
I have recently gathered a complete set of all the above (outside of the Goodacre, but I'm still looking for that one) and placing them all into one Registry made sense to me.

RBinTex

Why not. If you build it and no one comes - who cares?

TAClough

<< <i>I think it would be a good idea for PCGS to offer a Sacagawea Registry where the Mint State and the Proof coins are combined into one.

This would include Satin Finish coins. The complete registry would still only be a little over 30 coins (as of 2007). What do you think? A good idea, or not?

Edited to add:
I have recently gathered a complete set of all the above (outside of the Goodacre, but I'm still looking for that one) and placing them all into one Registry made sense to me. >>



A lot of collectors of the "Modern" series collect both Proof and Circulation strikes, so why not have a set so they all can be under "one roof"

LindeDad

Are you thinking that they would actully have a set with Business Strike, Satin Finish, And Proof coins in it?
Yikes that might be something somebody would collect. So no way would it fly in the registry.

braddick

"A lot of collectors of the "Modern" series collect both Proof and Circulation strikes, so why not have a set so they all can be under "one roof""<IMG src="i/expressions/3Devil.gif" border=0>

Exactly. PCGS does for the Kennedy series (providing one set that allows for both Proof and Mint State coins within). Why not the Sacagaweas?

Bossman88

I fully support the idea.

I think they should have combined MS/PR registry sets
for all modern coins that are being minted.

Regards, Larry

Griv