Holy carp! Some early commems on ebay...

cheezhed

Commem cache

Not mine and no interest in sale, but what do you guys think?

Some of theses are going for moon money.

mach19

Wow !!! Nice coins

a039

They all look dipped out.

dizzyfoxx

CarlWohlforth

They remind me of a thread about a year or less ago. A fellow reported he and his family inherited a large collection from their grandfather. It had some early proof sets and other goodies but was mostly tons of neat commems. He posted many photos here on one or two threads.

TomB

This seller has been discussed ad nauseum on these boards and the board members who have purchased (over)priced coins from him have been far from universally happy.

CarlWohlforth

I guess TomB is right and I'm thinking of something else...

savoyspecial

this isnt that FDC = fluer du coin guy is it?

greg

WinPitcher

They reminded me of that same guy and his cousins, however this seller is not them.


Steve

LeeG

No return policy say's it all for me.

cheezhed

<< <i>This seller has been discussed ad nauseum on these boards and the board members who have purchased (over)priced coins from him have been far from universally happy. >>



Oops! Didn't know this guy has been brought up before. The auctions seemed a little less than on the level. Thanks to all who posted comments and insight.

Tom

fc

he takes pics that are deceptive. makes the coin look better then
it really is.

if you think it is a 66, in your mind knock it down 3 points and that
is probably what it is.

Zoins

mtc3015 has a 554/100% rating and his DSRs are pretty high as well. If you check on toolhaus, he has 3 neutrals from 3 people 6 months and older and 3 negs from a single person. One of the people that gave him a neutral is centsles!

Will the new eBay feedback rules change this?

pursuitofliberty

I don't know if this seller has been discussed, nor do I care ... but a look through 5 pictures is enough for me. Every coin was proceesed, and probably shot at it's most flattering angle

Broadstruck

I think his Grandfather must have been the inventor of E*Z*EST.

Bear

Worthy of a ttt.

I was tempted to bid,

until I read the comments

on this thread. Thank you all.

grip

Raw,no return=GOTCHA!

Connecticoin

I still cannot figure out why this seller gets such strong money for his dipped out crap. There are other sellers like this (like ebay seller "hsturn"), but they do not get near as strong money as this "mtc" chump.

DJCoinz

Not this guy again...

Broadstruck

Estate Sale and Grandfather = Fresh Material never seen by a TPG?

Which in turn has EBay'RS bidding like money grows on trees?

Coll3ctor

"Holy Carp"


lol

Bear

If the coins were really as nice as depicted,

they would have been slabbed as very high grade.

No slab, no return, no accurate grading, means... NO BID

BY ME.

roadrunner

He must have a lot of grandfathers.

roadrunner

Moki

Here's a previous thread regarding this seller, mtc3015:

mtc3015

edited to add: In the previously anaylzed purchases from some forum members here, it appears that bidders would spend less and get nicer coins by purchasing PCGS or NGC graded coins. In almost all cases, the winning bidder greatly overpaid when the coin was finally viewed in hand.

Broadstruck

He must have a lot of grandfathers.

Goldbully

Russ said it best........................................





Earlier MTC Link

pontiacinf

all crap, smoke n mirrors

and its a dam shame, cause Im still searching for a CT terc to replace the one I let go

Zoins

Those older threads are very informative.

He certainly knows how to sell ... and doesn't even need third-world slabs.

Those envelopes probably help generate interest.

mozin

I cannot believe the crazy bidders this seller attracts.

nutz4coinz

I was checking out some of those, and the money is freakin' NUTZ for raw, no return policy coins. As I scrolled they listings (looking for something to spend my coupon on), then noticed the sellers name, remembered the threads, and said 'bye bye' to his listings.