Newp, 1858 Half Dollar W/ Blundered "8" & a question.

pinealbany

Just got this coin today and took some pics.
1) Is this coin cleaned? Please see the sellers pics and my pics?
2) If not cleaned, what would you guys grade it?
3) Is it worth submitting?

SELLERS PICS:





MY PICS:

STONE

It does look like altered surfaces.

Overall the details grade is 55 (+ or - 1) in my book.

Wouldn't know if its worth submitting.

ricko

This is not my focus series.. but I would say - not cleaned... and while I cannot guarantee a grade, it seems like it would be worth submitting. Cheers, RickO

GoldenEyeNumismatics

Cleaned (heavily dipped) and retoned.

LindeDad

Neat die clashing on the reverse. And sorry but I will agree cleaned and or lightly circulated at one time way back when. Then put away and retoned. I see this at best being a EF45 but probably getting a BB at the top two graders.

seemyauction

Great Coin..........


Will it grade ??? 50-50 chance


Look under the wing on the right side.....awesome


What seems odd to me is the heavy contact marks in the fields......