Options
80s Star basketball- Any experts out there?
CDsNuts
Posts: 10,092 ✭
I'm looking to put together a nice 1984-85 Star set, but I'm unclear about the counterfeiting/illegal printing situation. Here are my questions:
- Were only the good cards counterfeited and/or printed years later, or did they do every team set?
- There seems to be an inordinate number of the crappy team sets available, and sellers seem to have the same combination of sets. Anybody know why this is? For example, I just bought a lot of 13 team sets, and I see another seller is selling the same exact sets individually in their bags. What are the odds that two different sellers have the same exact team sets?
- If there are fake/illegal bagged sets out there, is there any way to tell the differences between them and legit sets by looking at the plastic bag and how it's sealed?
Thanks.
Lee
- Were only the good cards counterfeited and/or printed years later, or did they do every team set?
- There seems to be an inordinate number of the crappy team sets available, and sellers seem to have the same combination of sets. Anybody know why this is? For example, I just bought a lot of 13 team sets, and I see another seller is selling the same exact sets individually in their bags. What are the odds that two different sellers have the same exact team sets?
- If there are fake/illegal bagged sets out there, is there any way to tell the differences between them and legit sets by looking at the plastic bag and how it's sealed?
Thanks.
Lee
0
Comments
Raw: Tony Gonzalez (low #'d cards, and especially 1/1's) and Steve Young.
Article Re: Robert Levin Lawsuit
Dear Babe: In the 1980s, I stumbled upon a limited printing of Star basketball cards. I ordered a complete set in 1984. I got Michael Jordan's card No. 288, Jordan's Gold Olympics card (195) and Jordan as a Chicago Bull (101). The set also has Charles Barkley's rookie card. I have the whole set (not in a box) of 288. They say "Star '85" on them. _ John Muhoberac, Mount Joy, Pa.
It sounds as if you might have the real deal here if you got them back in 1984 or '85. These cards have been counterfeited and a number of "original" cards were supposedly found years later. In 1997, I reported that the NBA had sued the former Robert Levin, owner/producer of Star cards, and Shop at Home, the TV cable sales channel, to stop distribution of the cards. "The lawsuit was settled in our favor," said the NBA's Matt Bourne. "It was a civil litigation and he ultimately agreed to turn over the cards for destruction." The NBA reached an out-of- court settlement with Shop at Home. While Levin was licensed to make cards in the mid-1980s, there was no license for the second run that was produced in the mid-1990s. No one knows how many of those unlicensed cards made it into the secondary marketplace via SAH. The cards came in team bags.
I've been told that an expert can tell if the bag is an original or from the so called "warehouse" find, which we now know were just cards printed. Even though the Jordan cards were the most valuable, there wasn't any evidence back in 1997 to indicate that any of his cards or the Bulls sets were among the cards printed illegally. The scandal aside, assuming your set is authentic, you're looking at a set that Beckett's yearly basketball lists for $4,800 in "near mint" condition. Jordan's rookie card (101) lists for $2,800 - it's been at that spot for a decade. The other two Jordan cards book at $375 each. They'll be worth even more if they earn high grades from one of the top grading companies. Barkley (202) lists for $225. The guide says the original production run was supposedly limited to just 3,000 sets.
/s/ JackWESQ
PLAINTIFF: NBA Properties, Inc
DEFENDANT: Who's Who Productions, Inc (Terminated 3/31/1998);
Value Vision International, Inc;
Star International Inc;
Sports Collectibles, Inc (Terminated 7/9/1998);
Shop at Home, Inc (Terminated 7/15/1998);
Perahia, David DBA Baseball Card Mint (Terminated 4/9/1998);
MJD Marketing, Inc DBA Creative Marketing Concepts (Terminated
7/8/1998);
Mezak, Michael;
Madison Sports Management, Inc;
Levin, Robert S;
Levin, Joyce V;
Kruk, George M;
Kruk Cards, Inc DBA George Kruk Cards;
Iwakoshi, Daryl DBA Iscount Sportscard Co (Terminated 4/9/1998);
Home Shopping Network Inc;
Gordon, Alan F DBA All American Sports Card Co (Terminated
8/3/1998);
Furie, Larry DBA Kcj's Sports Cards (Terminated 4/9/1998);
Fillers, Gary B;
Dodd Printers, Inc;
Destiny International, Inc;
Demarco, James A;
Deangelis, Jack DBA Gotta Have It Collectibles;
Color Systems, Ltd, Inc;
Collectors Alliance, Inc;
Collectors Advantage, Inc;
Bernstein, Stan DBA Stan "the Man" Sportscards (Terminated
4/13/1998);
Asset Marketing Services, Inc DBA Preferred Customer Service
(Terminated 7/15/1998)
CROSS-CLAIMANT: Sports Collectibles, Inc;
Shop at Home, Inc;
Mezak, Michael;
Madison Sports Management, Inc;
Kruk, George M (Terminated 7/9/1998);
Kruk Cards, Inc DBA George Kruk Cards (Terminated 7/9/1998);
Fillers, Gary B;
Demarco, James A;
Color Systems, Ltd, Inc;
Collectors Alliance, Inc
CROSS-DEFENDANT: Star International Inc;
Sports Collectibles, Inc;
NBA Properties, Inc;
Levin, Robert S;
Kruk, George M;
Collectors Alliance, Inc
THIRD-PARTY DEFT: Madison Sports Management, Inc (Terminated 7/30/1998);
Lipeles, Don;
Kruk, George;
Iwakoshi, Daryl DBA Iscount Sportscard Co;
Desola, Michael
THIRD-PARTY PLTF: Sports Collectibles, Inc;
Mezak, Michael;
Fillers, Gary B;
Collectors Alliance, Inc
DOCKET CASE NUMBER: 9:97cv8517
FILING DATE: 7/2/1997
JURISDICTION: Federal Question
JUDGE: Graham, Donald L
NATURE OF SUIT: 840 Trademark
FILING TYPE: Civil
CAUSE: Trademark Infringement (Lanham Act)15 USC 1125
JURY DEMAND: Defendant
STATUS: Case Closed
PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY(S):
McGovern, Amanda Marie [COR LD NTC]
Schafer, Harry Richard [COR LD NTC]
Kenny Nachwalter Seymour Arnold Critchlow & Spector
Miami Center 201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 1100
Miami, FL, USA 33131-4327
305-373-1000 FTS 372-1861
Deutsch, Ayala [COR LD NTC]
Nba Properties Inc
645 5TH Avenue
New York, NY, USA 10022
212-407-8000
DEFENDANT ATTORNEY(S):
Pollack, Gary William [COR LD NTC]
1 SE 3RD Avenue
Miami, FL, USA 33131
FTS 446-2328 305-446-6723 Suite 1260
Valladares, Debra Ann [COR LD NTC]
1855 Coral Way
Miami, FL, USA 33145-2730
FTS 856-4090 305-856-0078
Katz, Jeffrey A [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 8/3/1998)
2712 N 7TH Street
Phoenix, AZ, USA 85006-1090
Feldman, David [COR LD NTC]
407 Lincoln Road
Miami Beach, FL, USA 33139-3059
305-534-4721 Suite Ph Ne
Russell, Holiday Hunt [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/15/1998)
Berger Singerman
Las Olas Centre II 350 E Las Olas Boulevard Suite 1000
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA 33301
954-525-9900 Address Terminated On 7/ 6/ 00 FTS 523-2872
Berger, Mitchell Wayne [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/15/1998)
Berger Singerman
Las Olas Centre II 350 E Las Olas Boulevard Suite 1000
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA 33301
954-525-9900 FTS 523-2872
Henry, Nancy Hagan [COR LD NTC]
Reid, Benjamine [COR LD NTC]
Carlton Fields
100 SE 2ND Street Suite 4000 PO Box 019101
Miami, FL, USA 33131-9101
305-530-0050 FTS 530-0055
Buschbom, Ronald Lee [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/8/1998)
Conroy Simberg Ganon Krevans & Abel
2000 Main Street Suite 702
Fort Myers, FL, USA 33901
941-337-1101 FTS 334-3383
Friedman, Dale Lyn [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/8/1998)
Conroy Simberg Ganon Krevans & Abel
3440 Hollywood Boulevard 2ND Floor
Hollywood, FL, USA 33021
954-961-1400 FTS 967-8577
Pollack, David H [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 4/9/1998)
David H Pollack
540 Brickell Key Drive Suite C-1
Miami, FL, USA 33131
305-372-5900 FTS 372-5904
Fertel, Alan Keith [COR LD NTC]
Ferrell Schultz Carter Zumpano & Fertel
201 S Biscayne Boulevard 34TH Floor Miami Center
Miami, FL, USA 33131-4325
305-371-8585 FTS 371-5732
Lundeen, Mitchell Lee [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 4/3/1998)
George Hartz Lundeen Flagg & Fulmer
4800 Le Jeune Road
Coral Gables, FL, USA 33146
305-662-4800 FTS 667-8015
Hodkin, Adam Jay [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 9/23/1997)
Holland & Knight
1 E Broward Boulevard Suite 1300
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA 33301-4811
954-525-1000 Address Terminated On 10/ 4/ 02 FTS 468-7932
Gaffigan, Stephen Michael [COR LD NTC]
Kluger Peretz Kaplan & Berlin
Miami Center 201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 1700
Miami, FL, USA 33131-8424
305-379-9000 Address Terminated On 11/ 17/ 00 FTS 379-3428
Chesal, Michael B [COR LD NTC]
Peretz, Steven Ira [COR LD NTC]
Kluger Peretz Kaplan & Berlin
Miami Center 201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 1700
Miami, FL, USA 33131-8424
305-379-9000 FTS 379-3428
Lawson, Jennifer Karen [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/9/1998)
Malloy & Malloy
2800 SW 3RD Avenue
Miami, FL, USA 33129
305-858-8000 Address Terminated On 7/ 10/ 03
Malloy, John Cyril, III [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/9/1998)
Malloy & Malloy
2800 SW 3RD Avenue
Miami, FL, USA 33129
305-858-8000 FTS 858-0008
Siff, Steven E [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/15/1998)
McDermott Will & Emery
201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 2200
Miami, FL, USA 33131-4336
305-358-3500 FTS 347-6500 305-347-6511
Fischer, Dianne Olivia [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/15/1998)
McDermott Will & Emery
201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 2200
Miami, FL, USA 33131-4336
305-358-3500 FTS 347-6500 305-347-6542
Aronson, Jonathan Bruce [COR LD NTC]
Essington, Michael Patrick [COR LD NTC]
Rodriguez Aronson & Essington
2121 Ponce De Leon Boulevard Suite 730
Miami, FL, USA 33134
305-774-1477 FTS 774-1075
Cirasuolo, Anne T [COR LD NTC]
Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker
International Place 100 SE 2ND Street Suite 3800
Miami, FL, USA 33131
305-374-4400
Kaplan, James Miller [COR LD NTC]
Zeena, William, Jr [COR LD NTC]
Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker
International Place 100 SE 2ND Street Suite 3800
Miami, FL, USA 33131
305-374-4400 FTS 579-0261
Nystrom, Eric J [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/15/1998)
Winthrop & Weinstine
30 East 7TH Street 3200 Minnesota World Trade Center
St Paul, MN, USA 55101
651-290-8400
Cottrell, Patricia J [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/15/1998)
Wyatt Tarrant & Combs
2525 West End Avenue Suite 1500
Nashville, TN, USA 37203-1423
615-244-0020
ADDITIONAL PARTY ATTORNEY(S):
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Valladares, Debra Ann [COR LD NTC]
1855 Coral Way
Miami, FL, USA 33145-2730
FTS 856-4090 305-856-0078
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Russell, Holiday Hunt [COR LD NTC]
Berger Singerman
Las Olas Centre II 350 E Las Olas Boulevard Suite 1000
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA 33301
954-525-9900 Address Terminated On 7/ 6/ 00 FTS 523-2872
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Berger, Mitchell Wayne [COR LD NTC]
Berger Singerman
Las Olas Centre II 350 E Las Olas Boulevard Suite 1000
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA 33301
954-525-9900 FTS 523-2872
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Henry, Nancy Hagan [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 3/26/1998)
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Reid, Benjamine [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/9/1998)
Carlton Fields
100 SE 2ND Street Suite 4000 PO Box 019101
Miami, FL, USA 33131-9101
305-530-0050 FTS 530-0055
FOR THE THIRD-PARTY DEFT
Pollack, David H [COR LD NTC]
David H Pollack
540 Brickell Key Drive Suite C-1
Miami, FL, USA 33131
305-372-5900 FTS 372-5904
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Fertel, Alan Keith [COR LD NTC]
FOR THE THIRD-PARTY DEFT
Fertel, Alan Keith [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/30/1998)
Ferrell Schultz Carter Zumpano & Fertel
201 S Biscayne Boulevard 34TH Floor Miami Center
Miami, FL, USA 33131-4325
305-371-8585 FTS 371-5732
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Lundeen, Mitchell Lee [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 4/3/1998)
George Hartz Lundeen Flagg & Fulmer
4800 Le Jeune Road
Coral Gables, FL, USA 33146
305-662-4800 FTS 667-8015
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Hodkin, Adam Jay [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 9/23/1997)
Holland & Knight
1 E Broward Boulevard Suite 1300
Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA 33301-4811
954-525-1000 Address Terminated On 10/ 4/ 02 FTS 468-7932
FOR THE CROSS-DEFENDANT
Schafer, Harry Richard [COR LD NTC]
Kenny Nachwalter Seymour Arnold Critchlow & Spector
Miami Center 201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 1100
Miami, FL, USA 33131-4327
305-373-1000 FTS 372-1861
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Chesal, Michael B [COR LD NTC]
FOR THE THIRD-PARTY PLTF
Chesal, Michael B [COR LD NTC]
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Peretz, Steven Ira [COR LD NTC]
FOR THE THIRD-PARTY PLTF
Peretz, Steven Ira [COR LD NTC]
Kluger Peretz Kaplan & Berlin
Miami Center 201 S Biscayne Boulevard Suite 1700
Miami, FL, USA 33131-8424
305-379-9000 FTS 379-3428
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Lawson, Jennifer Karen [COR LD NTC]
FOR THE THIRD-PARTY PLTF
Lawson, Jennifer Karen [COR LD NTC]
Malloy & Malloy
2800 SW 3RD Avenue
Miami, FL, USA 33129
305-858-8000 Address Terminated On 7/ 10/ 03
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Malloy, John Cyril, III [COR LD NTC]
FOR THE THIRD-PARTY PLTF
Malloy, John Cyril, III [COR LD NTC]
Malloy & Malloy
2800 SW 3RD Avenue
Miami, FL, USA 33129
305-858-8000 FTS 858-0008
FOR THE CROSS-DEFENDANT
Deutsch, Ayala [COR LD NTC]
Nba Properties Inc
645 5TH Avenue
New York, NY, USA 10022
212-407-8000
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Aronson, Jonathan Bruce [COR LD NTC] (Terminated 7/9/1998)
Rodriguez Aronson & Essington
2121 Ponce De Leon Boulevard Suite 730
Miami, FL, USA 33134
305-774-1477 FTS 774-1075
FOR THE CROSS-DEFENDANT
Cirasuolo, Anne T [COR LD NTC]
Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker
International Place 100 SE 2ND Street Suite 3800
Miami, FL, USA 33131
305-374-4400
FOR THE CROSS-DEFENDANT
Kaplan, James Miller [COR LD NTC]
Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker
International Place 100 SE 2ND Street Suite 3800
Miami, FL, USA 33131
305-374-4400 FTS 579-0261
FOR THE CROSS-CLAIMANT
Cottrell, Patricia J [COR LD NTC]
Wyatt Tarrant & Combs
2525 West End Avenue Suite 1500
Nashville, TN, USA 37203-1423
615-244-0020
THE COURT UPDATED THIS RECORD ON: 12/13/2003 05:49:00 AM
<< <i>I'm looking to put together a nice 1984-85 Star set, but I'm unclear about the counterfeiting/illegal printing situation. Here are my questions:
- Were only the good cards counterfeited and/or printed years later, or did they do every team set?
- There seems to be an inordinate number of the crappy team sets available, and sellers seem to have the same combination of sets. Anybody know why this is? For example, I just bought a lot of 13 team sets, and I see another seller is selling the same exact sets individually in their bags. What are the odds that two different sellers have the same exact team sets?
- If there are fake/illegal bagged sets out there, is there any way to tell the differences between them and legit sets by looking at the plastic bag and how it's sealed?
Thanks.
Lee >>
I use to be big into Star back in the glory days, boom days of 92-94. I thought I couldn't miss....well, I did learn a good lesson about "hot investments" and "can't miss opportunities".
I'm not an expert by any stretch, although I have observed the market for awhile...
-It seems like some bags from 84/85 are in higher quantity than others. Compare the cheaper bags, the $10-20 ones, with the Jordan Olympic bag, or the Rockets or Jazz. I think Indiana use to be the shortest print set in 84/85 (I think 2,000? and the others were 4-5,000). It use to sell for a premium, it was $40-60, and the other common bags were $15-20.
-Kruk Cards has been selling *alot* of team bags and sets. Too many for my tastes. I dont know what the story is there. Maybe take note of the bags they have in high quantity. It's not at all an indictment of them, they might be perfectly legitimate. Nothing against Kruk, but its been alot.
With Star in general, and with 84/85, I think the cloud of suspicion and doubt is worst than reality. The reality is, the bags still have some value. Not nearly as much as they use to. But if they were reprinted so heavily, why aren't they all $5 bags by now?
Some cards have gone way down in value. Like the Gatorade Barkley, short print. It use to be $500, and now it's $20-30. But its not true for every other bag, like the Jordan Olympic bag, Olajuwon's rookie, Stockton.
Then you factor in PSA, and the fact that they don't grade them. If they did, and registry sets caught on, then how high could they go.
Isn't the Jordan bag still $1,500-2,000 graded? It's hard to imagine that it got heavily reprinted and it's still selling for that much. That's what I've never understood. Maybe contact some of the Star experts, like Steve Taft, and see what the differences are or what the story is.
Dimes: 54S, 53P, 50P, 49S, 45D+S, 44S, 43D, 41S, 40D+S, 39D+S, 38D+S, 37D+S, 36S, 35D+S, all 16-34's
Quarters: 52S, 47S, 46S, 40S, 39S, 38S, 37D+S, 36D+S, 35D, 34D, 32D+S
74 Topps: 37,38,46,47,48,138,151,193,210,214,223,241,256,264,268,277,289,316,435,552,570,577,592,602,610,654,655
1997 Finest silver: 115, 135, 139, 145, 310
1995 Ultra Gold Medallion Sets: Golden Prospects, HR Kings, On-Base Leaders, Power Plus, RBI Kings, Rising Stars
Raw: Tony Gonzalez (low #'d cards, and especially 1/1's) and Steve Young.
My question - were all team sets re-printed, or just the ones listed in the article like the Bulls set and Olympic set? So if you have a Clippers or Pacers team set, is it definitely real, or were those re-printed as well?
I have a few NBA press releases regarding the law suit. I'll see if I can find them when I get home tonight. The Levin / Shop at Home law suit never indicated that cards previously issued were reprinted, rather that "newly discovered" sets purported printed in the 80's and subsequently found in the 90's were, in fact, printed in the 90's. This sets included a 1986 Crunch 'n Munch All Star set, 1986 Lite All Star set, 1986 Bulls Arena set, a 10 card 1984 Michael Jordan Olympic set and a 10 card 1984 mixed player Olympic set. These sets are very easy to identify because they have different colored boarders. I have a few of these sets and will post some pictures this evening.
BWT, did you ever get that Yaz rookie graded?
Mike
Luv the new avatar. Larry rocks!
Most counferfeits found have just been of the superstar cards, not the whole set. However, nothing stops a crook from substituting the fake for the real one inside a team set, leaving all the less important real ones there, and selling the real one separately.
As for dealers with quantities of the same sets, I can't ansewr that without knowing more about the dealers.
Nick
Reap the whirlwind.
Need to buy something for the wife or girlfriend? Check out Vintage Designer Clothing.
This is an excerpt from an SCD press release when they started grading Star basketball cards. It also appeared in the Feb 1, 2002 print issue. Keep in mind that this info was current as of 2002 and there may have been developments since. The article establishes Steve Taft and Todd Crosner's expertise with Star basketball cards and indicates that they are (were) the two Star authenticators for SCD. It then goes on to state that...
You can probably deal directly with Taft at Steve Taft Enterprises and Crosner at Santa Monica Sports Cards. Both are located in California.
Mike
10 card Jordan Oylmpic set (sorry, bad scan)...
Mike
Kruk does sell a lot of bagged sets. I bought a 1983 All Star Set for $10 a while back from them. Pretty cool, with Dr. J, Bird, Magic, Kareem, etc. Tuff borders too. Thinking about picking up some other non-Jordan sets.
Kiss me twice.....let's party.
<< <i>I only buy baseball Star Co. sets from 83 to 87, b/c no one would ever waste their time counterfeiting them.
Kruk does sell a lot of bagged sets. I bought a 1983 All Star Set for $10 a while back from them. Pretty cool, with Dr. J, Bird, Magic, Kareem, etc. Tuff borders too. Thinking about picking up some other non-Jordan sets. >>
Kruk huh.. I noticed he is listed as one of the defendants on the Lawsuit posted above. Or am I reading it wrong?? Anyhow it seems he has had a pretty hefty supply of star cards for years now
<< <i>
<< <i>I only buy baseball Star Co. sets from 83 to 87, b/c no one would ever waste their time counterfeiting them.
Kruk does sell a lot of bagged sets. I bought a 1983 All Star Set for $10 a while back from them. Pretty cool, with Dr. J, Bird, Magic, Kareem, etc. Tuff borders too. Thinking about picking up some other non-Jordan sets. >>
Kruk huh.. I noticed he is listed as one of the defendants on the Lawsuit posted above. Or am I reading it wrong?? Anyhow it seems he has had a pretty hefty supply of star cards for years now >>
They have been selling probably in the 100's of the 1983-84 Star Lakers Team bags
1. 75-76 Topps Keith/Jamaal Wilkes in Psa 8+
2. 1971-72 Trio stickers PSA 8+
3. BSKB 1977-78 topps psa 10
Basketball Autos
1992 Courtside Flashback
Action Packed HOF Autos(need elvin hayes,both bill bradley,and the 1st bill walton)
2001 and 2005 Greats of the Game
UD=retro,epic,legends,legendary,generations and chronology
2006 Topps Style 1952 Fan Favorites Autos #/10 (Refractor Autos)
Press Pass Legends
I'd be willing to bet that if you picked up an old SCD from the late 80s or early 90s you will see some of the same stuff they have in their ebay store now.
<< <i>I find it hard to believe that these unscrupulous people DIDN'T reprint the Jordan cards. >>
BINGO. Why wouldnt they reprint or counterfeit a $2,000 card?
<< <i>
<< <i>I find it hard to believe that these unscrupulous people DIDN'T reprint the Jordan cards. >>
BINGO. Why wouldnt they reprint or counterfeit a $2,000 card? >>
took about 10 seconds to find via the search function..
LINK>>>