WHAT IS THE RAREST SILVER EAGLE!

achillesaero

What is the rarest silver eagle since 1986 to be graded and pop to have!...............and price for that much?.........minus the 1995 proof.

mach19

I think it's the 2006-W 20th anniversary First stike MS-70?

fishcooker

The rarest would have to be a circulated one.

rgl1345

any one without milk spots is rare

fishcooker

I have nearly 200, and none have spots.

amercoin

<< <i>The rarest would have to be a circulated one. >>



That can't be rare . I picked one up at the bank about 3 months ago for a dollar.

OPA

<< <i>I think it's the 2006-W 20th anniversary First stike MS-70? >>



It's one of the most expensive ones...

2manycoins2fewfunds

I think based on label alone it might be a 2006-W First Strike ASE MS70 without.........I stress without the 20 Anniversary label.

SUMORADA

In the Holiday Spirit..........It is also known as the "Eagle of Christmas Past"..........ka........ching!......................Happy Holidays!

RayNY2E

My First PIctures taken in a hurry,soo PLEASE be kind....I Have ALOT to Learn! These have a Population of 105 as of Dec.19,2007. These two Are in My Registry Sets. Ray in Florida..

SUMORADA

Wow RayNY2E,

great givaway count me in !.............and thanks...

Griv

There are a few "rouge" MS70s out there 86 (3), 88 (1), 95 (1), 97 (3) and 98 (4), but I have NEVER seen one for sale so they are either broken out of the slabs and not reported or milked up so bad no one would try to sell it. Now there seems to be 4 1996 MS70s so I think they are the winner but I'm not sure why they were even graded since PCGS was only supposed to allow W silver to grade 70. Hmmm. Other than those it goes to the 1987 PR70DCAM with a pop of 12. My favorite.

greymars

I have the 2002 with the American flag symbol and a 2004 PCGS ASE Collectors club slabs

Neither one of them have any spots on them at this time.

Gary

FloridaBill

<< <i> I think based on label alone it might be a 2006-W First Strike ASE MS70 without.........I stress without the 20 Anniversary label. >>




Really? I currently have a live auction on ebay for a 20 pack of 2006-W pcgs ASE that were graded before PCGS gave a 70 grade....and it's not getting much attention...

FloridaBill (XF)

Bochiman

Depends on whether or not you are sticking to PCGS grades or open to NGC.
That has a bit of bearing in it, I think

Deadhorse

<< <i>I have nearly 200, and none have spots. >>



Same here, though I've got close to 800 that I bought at spot price or less as pure bullion over the years.

None have milk spots, including the slabbed ones.

Bochiman

<< <i>

<< <i> I think based on label alone it might be a 2006-W First Strike ASE MS70 without.........I stress without the 20 Anniversary label. >>




Really? I currently have a live auction on ebay for a 20 pack of 2006-W pcgs ASE that were graded before PCGS gave a 70 grade....and it's not getting much attention...

FloridaBill (XF) >>



Just because they were graded before PCGS gave the MS70 grade doesn't mean most people are willing to gamble. If I were interested in buying them, for the gamble, and I read "...these were graded prior to PCGS giving the MS70 grade..." then I would think "hey, he knows what he is talking about and isn't likely to leave large money on the table so it is doubtful these would upgrade. That and the fact that there aren't a ton of them out there...that tells me PCGS isn't giving them out like candy on Halloween.

291fifth

The term "rare" and "silver eagle" should never be used in the same sentence.

Gemineye

<< <i>The rarest would have to be a circulated one. >>


None were ever issued to be"circulated" into commerce as regular coinage.They were only issued for collectability.

fishcooker

I vaguely recall someone trying to get an eagle down to P-01. Did they make it?