Grey sheet price?1833 CBH in Pcgs AU-58..edit:Pic added

TennesseeDave

Would $725 be a fair price for this coin in this grade?Pcgs price guide is $600 in 55 and $1200 in 60.The coin has awsome eye appeal,no spots or toning exept light golden toning.






My mistake,1834 not 33(edit)

Barndog

a search of these forums would likely tell you that less than eight hundred for a PCGS AU-58 that is properly graded/originally skinned CBH is a good price and that the greysheet doesn't matter.

also, AU-58 grade/prices aren't listed on greysheet for halves, to the best of my recollection

AU58WALKERS

In my registry, PCGS priced my 1833 au58 at $900

AU58WALKERS

one of the most common pcgs au58 bust halves. be sure to get one you like.

Barndog

AU58Walkers...send that POS to me!

fishteeth

Really impossible to say without pics.
A good price for a true AU58 with nice eye appeal. If its a dipped out white 58 that might be a little high.

gecko109

With good eye appeal (and almost all 58's have that) $725 is a good buy. Barndog had it right, on certain type coins, throw the sheet out the window!

123cents

$700.00 max unless it has fantastic toning.

mozin

<< <i>Would $725 be a fair price for this coin in this grade?Pcgs price guide is $600 in 55 and $1200 in 60.The coin has awsome eye appeal,no spots or toning exept light golden toning. >>


I am trying to sift through your description. Light golden toning often means a dip some years back, just starting to retone. Awesome eye appeal on a white coin, I am thinking you see strong luster.

If you like the coin, as you say, $725 seems very reasonable.