Though I really like a lot of DCarr's designs, this is not one of my favorites.
I don't hate it- in fact, I rather like the concept- but the model's posture looks stiff and unnatural.
And on the version with the torch, the torch is too small, so it looks as though she squeezed her ice cream cone too hard and caused its contents to squirt upwards.
A very unnatural pose. Almost looks like the head is on backwards. The body is soulless and not much better than a stick drawing of a person. The rest of the coin is ok. The problem is the body is so distracting, it destroys the rest of the coin.
Overall grade: F
Appears to have been done by a child. Mr. Carr needs to study the human body.
<< <i>A very unnatural pose. Almost looks like the head is on backwards. The body is soulless and not much better than a stick drawing of a person. The rest of the coin is ok. The problem is the body is so distracting, it destroys the rest of the coin.
Overall grade: F
Appears to have been done by a child. Mr. Carr needs to study the human body. >>
Wow that was crazy harsh, it is so far more than I could do, I could not offer up that kind of criticism.
BTW, I prefer the "sunburst and globe" concept to the "industry" one with the gear on it. But both are okay, as concepts. More realistic modeling of the human figure, and these would be pretty neat. In fact, seeing some classical throwbacks like fasces and seated ladies in a modern coin design is kind of nice.
Would those designs be struck at the Spear Mint? TD
Numismatist. 50 year member ANA. Winner of four ANA Heath Literary Awards; three Wayte and Olga Raymond Literary Awards; Numismatist of the Year Award 2009, and Lifetime Achievement Award 2020. Winner numerous NLG Literary Awards.
Comments
I don't hate it- in fact, I rather like the concept- but the model's posture looks stiff and unnatural.
And on the version with the torch, the torch is too small, so it looks as though she squeezed her ice cream cone too hard and caused its contents to squirt upwards.
Proud recipient of two "You Suck" awards
Be right back, the copyright attorneys are at my door.................
The body is soulless and not much better than a stick drawing of a person.
The rest of the coin is ok.
The problem is the body is so distracting, it destroys the rest of the coin.
Overall grade: F
Appears to have been done by a child.
Mr. Carr needs to study the human body.
<< <i>A very unnatural pose. Almost looks like the head is on backwards.
The body is soulless and not much better than a stick drawing of a person.
The rest of the coin is ok.
The problem is the body is so distracting, it destroys the rest of the coin.
Overall grade: F
Appears to have been done by a child.
Mr. Carr needs to study the human body. >>
Wow that was crazy harsh, it is so far more than I could do, I could not offer up that kind of criticism.
I'm sure after the Hal Turner fun and games, though, Mr. Carr can handle it.
<< <i>Maybe she just needs a laptop computer....!! >>
I think the I phone has that covered.
<< <i>
<< <i>Maybe she just needs a laptop computer....!! >>
I think the I phone has that covered.
TD