Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

New respect for problem coins?



I posted a thread earlier about high detail problem coins VS low detail original coins. Which one is best to buy for equal money. There are numerous variables involved of course. However, after searching Heritage's upcoming coin auctions, I began to realize just how many ANACS holdered problem coins there actually are for sale. Without taking an actual census, I would guesstimate that over 1/3rd of their inventory in type coins from 1794 till about 1860 are problem coins. This further confirms my suspicion that soon, these "blacksheep of the hobby" will soon gain not only acceptance, but will prosper in the collections of the not-so-well heeled hobbyist like myself. We all want problem free, original surfaces, AU55 flowing hair half dimes, but very, very few of us could buy something like that with any frequency. If I aquire 1 coin every 2 years, maybe I could buy something like that, but how much fun would that be? Im not saying that more modern coinage (1916-present) will ever be popular in problem condition. But the earlier stuff is just so few and far between for higher grade original material.

Comments

  • Options
    pb2ypb2y Posts: 1,461 ✭
    I own a few of these??? they ain't for sale.image
    image

  • Options
    OverdateOverdate Posts: 7,320 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Problem coins on eBay often bring sizable fractions of the prices of their undamaged counterparts.


  • Options
    lordmarcovanlordmarcovan Posts: 45,441 ✭✭✭✭✭
    A lot of it depends on the problem(s). A cleaned Flowing Hair Half Dime is still a rare and desirable coin. Many early large cents have surface issues, which are sort of par for the course. For some issues, problem-free coins are the exception rather than the rule. I remember my quest to find a decent mid-grade Draped Bust half dime for my old type set- it was practically impossible. Everything I looked at was either bent or mutilated horribly, or was high grade and unaffordable. There was a real dearth of nice coins in the VG to Fine range. Since I was doing a slabbed type set at the time and accepting several different services but no net grade or problem coins, I had a really hard time. None of the candidates in my budget were slabbed or slabworthy. In the end, I had to settle for an ANACS G6 (lightly bent but no net grade), though the rest of my early type coins were Fine or better.

    If you are a collector of modest or intermediate means, like myself, it can be challenging. For some types in the affordable "collector" grades (like those pesky little Draped half dimes), the problem-free pieces just don't hit the market much- if somebody is lucky enough to find one, they hang on to it for the long term. Of course there are lovely, problem-free AU and MS survivors out there, but they're beyond the reach of your average Joe Numismatist.

    I have relaxed my stance on cleaned coins considerably. Problems like cleaning or questionable toning do not bother me much if the coin has eye appeal. Heavy scratches or ugly toning (even if original and natural) do. And everybody knows I've long had an appreciation for holed coins, but I don't mix the holeys into my unholed collections. Holed coins are fun to collect for many reasons I've enumerated before, and the market for them enjoys its own niche of sorts.

    Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.

  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,382 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Your posts read to me as though you are trying to convince yourself of the ultimate and complete acceptance within the hobby/industry of a strong market for net graded or problem coins. In a way, I think this is already here since there is a rather good market for many coins that fall within this category. However, to base your hopes on the guesstimated ANACS populations within the Heritage site is a very poor idea. One reason for this is that Heritage may very well own many of these coins and the best way to sell them is to get them in a holder. These coins might not sell during their auctions, but will be available on their website at a fixed price later. Essentially, it costs little-to-nothing for Heritage to stuff their auctions with stale material. Alternatively, many of these ANACS net graded coins might end up on the Heritage site because they are dumped there when their owners cannot sell them at a satisfactory level through other means. Therefore, simply because there might be many ANACS net graded coins on the Heritage site does not mean that folks are aggressively competing to obtain each piece.
    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options
    commoncents05commoncents05 Posts: 10,102 ✭✭✭
    Problem coins of a desirable series or a key date still brings a premium, but it will never be the same as a non-problem piece. Overall, I've found buying problem coins a losing deal. When you buy them, the price sounds great, half of what a non-problem would cost, saving you lots of money, but when you go to sell it, dealers beat you up and don't want it, and it is 10 times easier to sell a non-problem coin and get your money back. With a problem coin, its a gamble to how much you'll get for it, etc.

    -Paul
    Many Quality coins for sale at http://www.CommonCentsRareCoins.com
  • Options
    There is a market for problem coins. Like was said above, key dates or rare varieties with problems (which are often the only way they are available) may sell for decent money, but choice original coins will always bring more money than problem or not choice for the grade common date/variety coins.
    Greg Cohen

    Senior Numismatist

    Legend Rare Coin Auctions
  • Options
    CladiatorCladiator Posts: 18,353 ✭✭✭✭✭
    If it's common I have a very low tolerance for problems. If it's rare all I care about is whether or not it's genuine.
  • Options
    DennisHDennisH Posts: 14,044 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I pay very keen attention to circulated key date Morgans and VAMs in ANACS holders that are net graded for being "scratched". image
    When in doubt, don't.
  • Options


    << <i>Problem coins of a desirable series or a key date still brings a premium, but it will never be the same as a non-problem piece. Overall, I've found buying problem coins a losing deal. When you buy them, the price sounds great, half of what a non-problem would cost, saving you lots of money, but when you go to sell it, dealers beat you up and don't want it, and it is 10 times easier to sell a non-problem coin and get your money back. With a problem coin, its a gamble to how much you'll get for it, etc.

    -Paul >>



    Selling a problem coin, or any coin short of being very rare, directly to a dealer, is a losing proposition all day long. Their overhead dictates a lowball offer usually. If you walked in with something like a PCGS 64 CBQ, or something along those lines, you MAY get fair market value. But for any raw, or relatively common type coin, be ready to take a loss at a shop. That being said, there have been numerous occassions where I have bought a "problem" coin at a shop for a reasonable price, sent it to ANACS to get a details grade, and flipped the coin on the bay for as much as double my investment. Just one example was an 1806/5 half raw, obviously cleaned, but strong VF detail. After much haggling, I walked out of the store with it in hand for $200. Sent it into ANACS, came back VF30 details, sold it on the bay for $440. I've done it a few times with half cents as well. Theres no way this system would work on a common date Morgan, SLQ, or even sheild nickel IMO. Those coins can be found by the dozens in any shop. But ask yourself this....how many draped bust halves or quarters do you see at any given time in your local coin shop? These "rare" coins can be sleepers even with minor problems for a fair price!
  • Options
    I'm on a fixed income, and in almost all instances, even a VERY SCARCE coin, let alone a RARE one, would normally be beyond my means..... (specifically, my bust and seated dime collection)

    These so-called "problem"coins are often my only option.....


    Also, I have several darkside coins that would classify as problematic, but they are welcome in my collection, as in several instances there are less than 6-8 known, and in more than one case, only about 3 known.......

    In both these situations, in enjoying the coins for what they are, I am PROUD and PRIVILEGED to be their custodian for as long as I am able.....
  • Options
    MidLifeCrisisMidLifeCrisis Posts: 10,618 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>If it's common I have a very low tolerance for problems. If it's rare all I care about is whether or not it's genuine. >>


    I agree...but it has to be a very rare coin for me not to care about problems. image
  • Options
    MidLifeCrisisMidLifeCrisis Posts: 10,618 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>...in several instances there are less than 6-8 known, and in more than one case, only about 3 known.......

    In both these situations, in enjoying the coins for what they are, I am PROUD and PRIVILEGED to be their custodian for as long as I am able..... >>


    I could certainly make an exception for that kind of rarity...especially if they have an interesting story to go with them (as most such super rare coins do).
  • Options
    Thats exactly the point of this thread!!! There are FAR more collectors with a budget of say $250/month than there are collectors with a $2,500/month coin budget. It stands to reason that problem coins, and especially early material will always have a strong demand simply because MOST collectors cannot afford original early material. Unless your name is Gates, Buffett, or Winfrey, you might have to settle for a hairlined VF20 details draped bust dime. Again, I stress that my philosophy does not include all U.S. coins. There are PLENTY of nice original examples to go around for coins like seated dimes, liberty nickels, and trade dollars. But for stuff like draped bust anything, and flowing hair material, there isnt even a large enough supply of problem coins to meet demand! Count up all the flowing hair coinage you actually see at the next 3 or 4 shows, and my guess is you'd be able to count them all on your fingers and toes!
  • Options
    fcfc Posts: 12,805 ✭✭✭
    i would only consider a problem coin if it is truly rare.
    meaning i have never seen one for sale and along comes
    a truly rare coin. this basically means there is only 20 graded
    and maybe 50 exist for example. that describes quite a few
    half eagles.
  • Options
    JRoccoJRocco Posts: 14,277 ✭✭✭✭✭
    You know....I wouldn't turn away a Brasher Doubloon because someone cleaned it at one time...

    Problem coins are affordable coins in many cases.
    Some may purchase a replica in place of a rare piece in an album, I would prefer a nice real coin
    in that spot with a minor...and to me this is the key....minor problem. I do not want a problem
    coin with say major graffiti etched into the fields, but lines from an old cleaning with a jeweler's cloth...OK

    Problem coins will always have a place in our hobby for those that can't afford the same coin in a given grade that is pristine.

    Now this does not mean purchasing a problem coin that is a common coin frequently seen and inexpensive.
    Some coins are just plain "Interesting"
  • Options
    fcfc Posts: 12,805 ✭✭✭
    another exception when it comes to half eagles is
    any proof. i would love to own a proof in any condition.
    but once again, many only have a population of 5-25.
  • Options
    dorkkarldorkkarl Posts: 12,691 ✭✭✭
    there's nothing wrong w/ "problem" coins. there's something wrong w/ some people's opinions of them, though.

    buy what YOU like, & to he11 w/ all the naysayers

    K S
  • Options


    << <i>Again, I stress that my philosophy does not include all U.S. coins. There are PLENTY of nice original examples to go around for coins like seated dimes, liberty nickels, and trade dollars. >>



    I agree with your point but not your examples for nice original coins. Maybe for a type collector but a set collector of seated dimes would be hard pressed to complete a set without having problem coins. I do not collect dollars but I bet the same is true for trade dollars.

    In the land of the blind the one-eyed man is king.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file