Home PCGS Set Registry Forum
Options

Set Registry Weights

Just curious,

I was looking at the set registry weights for roosevelts for 1946-64 FB cirulation strikes and they do not seem representative what I would have thought. How are these numbers calculated. image

Comments

  • Options
    I've often wondered about weights of coins myself.

    I also have a problem with coins being allowed into a set when they do not
    seem to belong. for example, if a set is supposed to be for full band, or full head or full
    bell lines, why do they allow coins into the set that do not meet that criteria ?
  • Options
    LindeDadLindeDad Posts: 18,766 ✭✭✭✭✭
    why do they allow coins into the set that do not meet that criteria ?

    Money is the short answer. Just one example: what is the market price of a 1953-S MS65FB Franklin Half Dollar and a MS66 of the same.
  • Options
    etexmikeetexmike Posts: 6,795 ✭✭✭
    I think I understand the "weights" but I don't have to like them.

    I have a set of Early S Mint Morgans listed. My set is tied for 13th with 11 other sets. With the exception of 1 coin in 2 different sets they are all listed with the same grade coins. Most of the 11 sets look just like this.

    Date----------Grade-------------Pop----------Pop Higher

    1878-S--------MS 66 ------------467---------------20
    1879-S------- MS 67------------1028--------------70
    1880-S------- MS 67------------1433-------------138
    1881-S------- MS 67------------1256--------------82
    1882-S------- MS 67-------------560---------------32


    My set grades like this.

    Date--------------Grade------------Pop----------Pop Higher

    1878-S--------- MS 66 PL-----------7-----------------2
    1879-S--------- MS 67 PL----------41----------------2
    1880-S----------MS 67 PL---------109--------------18
    1881-S--------- MS 67 PL--------- 63----------------1
    1882-S----------MS 67-------------560--------------32

    The 11 sets plus mine all have "weighted" 66.67 grades. I guess the dates are just too common to warrant any more points. I would love to see mine listed as higher but in the end it doesn't really matter where my set falls on the list. I know the effort that I put into the set and would rather own it. I registered it and it is for my enjoyment even if nary another person appreciates it. image I'm just SanFranDreamin'. image

    -------------

    etexmike
Sign In or Register to comment.