Poll: Grade the Buff that I picked up at the Houston show... grade posted.

LincolnCentMan

Just for fun. Nothing more, nothing less. So how 'bout it? Btw, I procured this from David and Ginger Pike.



-David

LincolnCentMan

Any final guesses before I tell everyone?

-David

gyocomgd

I think it's missing a bit of definition on the bison's head, but other than that, she's pretty sweet!
(I guessed MS64. I have a feeling I'm going to be off by one or two...)

Numismanic

MS65

MFH

MS 63 - but I'm not that great with Buff's

LincolnCentMan

As of the time of this post. There were 36 people that graded it, with two additional "votes" that didnt grade it. Out of the 36, nobody graded it the same as the PCGS grade. I would have personally graded the coin a strong 63... and had to pay strong 63 money for the coin. In the end, I went to the show looking for a really nice dansco coin for that date. Since it was the best one I could find without buying one in a 65 holder, I ponied up the dough. Thanks to all who voted.

BTW... if you graded the coin XF45 or lower, I'm interested in buying some sight-seen full horn buffalos from you.

-David

Gemineye

I was a bit generous with a 64......!!

BlindedByEgo

<< <i>I was a bit generous with a 64......!! >>



Me, too. Nice looking 62, I think.

jhusman

I have got to get my picture skills going - I got a raw buff that must grade at least as high, if not higher than that one, plus it has some subtle color.

Also picked it up at the show, paid $20 for it.

Nice coin.

ricko

Wow... I said 65.... and still would say that .. looking again at the photo's... tricky grading.. Cheers, RickO