The most Amazing Reverse Toned Morgan (PCGS) I have ever seen (not my coin)...

uofa1285

The most Amazing Reverse Toned Morgan (PCGS) I have ever seen (not my coin)...I've seen bright colors, but never bright AND this rich (thick)-appearing...wow.

Link

Doug

sweetwilliet

Amazing toning, PCGS has been so strict, I'm a little surprised it made it into one of their new holders. Guess it could have been a regrade/reholder, but the coin is nice.

coindeuce

What a crying shame about the full thumb print in front of Liberty's portrait though A mishandled coin is a mishandled coin, color or not.

lasvegasteddy

i concur as that is one breath taking beauty.it sure would be very hard to part with.

Coxe

A shame it wasn't the obverse instead of the reverse. Maybe it would have hidden the thumbprint.

PrivateCoinCollector

This should not have made it past PCGS. It has to be AT.

renman95

<< <i>What a crying shame about the full thumb print in front of Liberty's portrait though A mishandled coin is a mishandled coin, color or not. >>



Can anybody here who works at a CSI-(city-of-your-choice) and can ID that fingerprint, call the local constable and aprehend the perpretrader with the fat thumb and take him jail. What a crying shame! Strangely enough, I just bought an 1882-S rainbow Morgan 2 days ago. The difference is the front is rainbowed.

BobaFett72

"A"mazing "T"oning indeed. bleh.

JRocco

<< <i>This should not have made it past PCGS. It has to be AT. >>



Can you take a minute to explain this comment PrivateCoinCollector?

circulated

<<This should not have made it past PCGS. It has to be AT.>>

PCGS graders were drinking kool aid? If this isn't AT I don't know what is!

stman

DUDE!!! Interesting toning/color. Now that's some "color." I'd like to see some pull-away and the color not all over the tops of the letters etc. and would like to see different shades of color inside the devices. Perhaps it blend a bit better, and could do without that spotty color stuff as well. I wish I could un-see the prints on the obverse. AND, it's not Battle Creek so it can't be much.

Bottom line.... "If it's pretty and you like it is all that matters." I learned that right here.

BECOKA

As we found out on this forum ( I won't mention names) some people have master the art of toning coins after they have been holdered.

dizzyfoxx

<< <i>DUDE!!! Interesting toning/color. Now that's some "color." I'd like to see some pull-away and the color not all over the tops of the letters etc. and would like to see different shades of color inside the devices. Perhaps it blend a bit better, and could do without that spotty color stuff as well. I wish I could un-see the prints on the obverse. AND, it's not Battle Creek so it can't be much.

Bottom line.... "If it's pretty and you like it is all that matters." I learned that right here. >>



Well spoken Steve... especially the comment about it "not being a Battle Creek so it can't be much".

MrD

In my opinion this is classic bag toning. They don't come more original IMHO

circulated

<<In my opinion this is classic bag toning. They don't come more original IMHO>>

You have some very crazy coins !

MrD

I have what people send me. I do the best I can with what comes to me.

stman

<< <i>If this isn't AT I don't know what is! >>



Might be




<< <i>In my opinion this is classic bag toning. They don't come more original IMHO >>



Might be. See? the new stman, I agree with everybody!!!! Everyday is a Holiday, and the glass is half full. Bless you all.

BAJJERFAN

I bet it don't look THAT razzle dazzle in hand.

MrD

Pretty close

uofa1285

If I had the dough, I would try to own it...looks 100% NT to me. I have owned literally hundreds and hundreds of NT Rainbow Morgans over the years and this one is tremendous.

Doug

Bear

'

TWQG

Nice coin

Myqqy

That's truly ironic that a reverse that intense would get paired with an ugly obverse with that kind of print on it...

gyocomgd

Don't take it to Willie Wonka's factory. It'll get eaten.

bestclser1

<< <i>If it looks to nice to be true then.............................................................. >>

You probably have never seen a real NT Moose color Morgan in hand.Bear,not directed at you as i know you have owned some beautiful coins.The problem with people who are always planting doubt about monster toned Morgans,and i dont collect reverse toned ones,so i have no interest in this coin,is that they have never seen one ,owned one,or are just plain jealous.Hey,what do i know,or Sunnywood,or GSA Guy,or Shep,Tom B,Curtis,Toneddollars,gemtone,coingame 2000,newmismitist,Art r.Mugno,Dragon,Kimmel,Fountainheadgold,Hadleydog,or any folks i forgot to mention who actually know real bag toning.JMHO

Hadleydog

A moose of a toner, and very much NT. Sorry stman, your wrong on this one. I have coins that show both pull-away on some portions while others have the devices covered. At least your response had some thought put into it.

dtkk49a

I would love to own that NT coin.

TONEDDOLLARS

The coin is not mine. I have seen it in hand, and its beautiful. Natural bag toning IMO.

Preussen

Better coin collecting through chemistry - Preussen

kryptonitecomics

NT....those that would say otherwise need to move on to posts about widgets.......or better yet.........Moderns.....plenty of other stuff to bash

ricko

Why is the Reverse shown on the label side of the slab? All I have seen have the obverse to the front. Cheers, RickO

bestclser1

You can request the grading services to slab reverse,or money side out,Ricko.

RotatedRainbows

<< <i>

<< <i>If this isn't AT I don't know what is! >>



Might be




<< <i>In my opinion this is classic bag toning. They don't come more original IMHO >>



Might be. See? the new stman, I agree with everybody!!!! Everyday is a Holiday, and the glass is half full. Bless you all. >>



Oh Boy!!! We are in trouble now!!!

pbfloyd

I think they are a sight to behold, but I could never buy one. My skill level at determining AT versus NT keeps me from it.

pharmer

<< <i>The coin is not mine. I have seen it in hand, and its beautiful. Natural bag toning IMO. >>



Who owns it now? Is it one of Larry's?

ricko

Thanks bestclser1... Cheers, RickO

segoja

For Sure a good coin.

Imagine what this coin would be worth with this color on the obverse?

TheKidCollector1991

Howely!
Awesome Toning!

TKC!

fivecents

Yabba dabba doo!!

Higashiyama

I actually like the obverse on this coin; it is clearly original, the fingerprint is old; the coin has character!

relicsncoins

I like my 82S.....

stman

<< <i>Sorry stman, your wrong on this one. I have coins that show both pull-away on some portions while others have the devices covered. At least your response had some thought put into it. >>



Hadleydog, sorry, I wasn't wrong, I said what I'd LIKE to see. I am entitled to say what I'd LIKE to see I hope.

My quote on your comment.....



<< <i>I'd like to see some pull-away >>

Frankcoins

PrivateCoinCollector


<< <i>This should not have made it past PCGS. It has to be AT. >>



I really trust your opinion. Especially your example of what a VF Morgan looks like...

http://professionalcoinbuyingservices.com/_wsn/page2.html

pharmer

<< <i>PrivateCoinCollector


<< <i>This should not have made it past PCGS. It has to be AT. >>



I really trust your opinion. Especially your exaple of what a VF Morgan looks like...

http://professionalcoinbuyingservices.com/_wsn/page2.html >>



Where it says integrity is paramont, it should be paramount.

kiyote

Eh, I threw in my bid, but I won't go any higher.. nice coin, though!

Connecticoin

<< <i>PrivateCoinCollector


<< <i>This should not have made it past PCGS. It has to be AT. >>



I really trust your opinion. Especially your exaple of what a VF Morgan looks like...

http://professionalcoinbuyingservices.com/_wsn/page2.html >>



The "Poor" Morgan looks like an AG3. So it all evens out!

57loaded

<< <i>What a crying shame about the full thumb print in front of Liberty's portrait though A mishandled coin is a mishandled coin, color or not. >>




Who knows who's thumb print that might be???

A beauty of a coin, however

kiyote

I bought this as a retirement gift for my older brother, who retired, kinda, at 52.

pharmer

<< <i>Eh, I threw in my bid, but I won't go any higher.. nice coin, though! >>



Looks about right, good luck.
-------------------------

kiyote

I don't think I have a chance.. this thing could go over $1,000!

Hadleydog

<< <i>..... this thing could go over $1,000! >>


Easily, although you never know on the 'bay. Color like this is rare.......imagine if it were on the obverse?