Here's an interesting coin post: Post a coin that...

dizzyfoxx

...if resubmitted raw, you doubt it would be placed back in a slab.

Let's see those "Lucky The First Time" beauties...

P.S. I'm not expecting much action on this thread, but let's give it a whirl.

eyore

I'll play, sent this coin to anacs.Then sent to ngc. it graded ms 64 both times

pharmer

Where's your example, dizy?

dizzyfoxx

<< <i>Where's your example, dizy? >>



Unfortunately I don't have one that meets this criteria. All of my coins are no brainer / shoe in / lock slabbers 10 out of 10 submissions.

pharmer

You're a legend in your own mind, and no mistake

eyore

yep should read more carefully, just so happens I have a 63 anacs robinson that I don't know how it got slabed.

dizzyfoxx

<< <i>You're a legend in your own mind, and no mistake >>



Thank you very much for the words of wisdom. Outstanding!

jayboxx

I thought the 1866 half was Dizzy's example

dizzyfoxx

<< <i>I thought the 1866 half was Dizzy's example >>



Ouch!!! ...and again, below the belt and the ref takes a point away.

FatMan

I believe this coin is AT. If submitted to anyone but NGC I suspect it would come back in a BB. I am sad to say I paid a hefty premium for this coin. One of the few that have paid my coin education.

dizzyfoxx

<< <i>I believe this coin is AT. If submitted to anyone but NGC I suspect it would come back in a BB. I am sad to say I paid a hefty premium for this coin. One of the few that have paid my coin education.



>>



Thanks Fats, I was hoping someone would "step up to the plate" with a 'serious' coin. That is pretty and it may or may not re-slab. In today's world, I'd be somewhat hesitant to send in anything pretty. Admittedly Pharmer, even my own, regardless of how confident I may be with my coins.

JRocco

Here is one in PCGS plastic

Mesquite

Here's another in a PCGS holder. The coin is obviously not a CAM.