PCGS slab ERRORS ON 2006 REV PR ASE $1

TRADECOIN

I just looked at my (10) PCGS REV. PR FIRST STRIKE ASE $1 and the holder reads 2006-W should read 2006-P . Should I send them back to PCGS ???

FatMan

Oops

Topdollarpaid

I would not send them back

SilverEagles92

Try it on eBay and make $1000!

TWQG

You'll pay postage for their ineptitude.

wondercoin

I returned my (10) mechanical errors in a heartbeat and encouraged others to do the same. I frankly think it is a very scummy thing to not return them - period end. I would hope that PCGS would consider cancelling the submission privileges/membership of anyone they find trying to profit on such an obvious mechanical error and not return them.

Wondercoin

MarineEAS1999

<< <i> I would hope that PCGS would consider cancelling the submission privileges/membership
of anyone they find trying to profit on such an obvious mechanical error and not return them. >>



I understand what you are saying, but PCGS profits from the "First Strike" designation which I
consider to be disingenuous as it is an unprovable fact. So it would be the pot calling the kettle
"black" if they tried to stop someone from profitting on their own property.

Its a free country and as long as you are not intentionally misrepresenting something then it
should be ok. JMHO

Bochiman

<< <i>I returned my (10) mechanical errors in a heartbeat and encouraged others to do the same. I frankly think it is a very scummy thing to not return them - period end. I would hope that PCGS would consider cancelling the submission privileges/membership of anyone they find trying to profit on such an obvious mechanical error and not return them.

Wondercoin >>



IF PCGS makes the mistake AND pays for the postal return, I would agree with you. But, PCGS made the mistake and it sounds like the member has to pay the return postage to get it corrected, right?
Is that right in your eyes? If the mistake was 100% PCGS? It isn't in my eyes.