Options
TONED BUFFALO -- REAL , MEMOREX, OVERPRICED???
This is a follow up to a thread started by dizzyfoxx in late March of this year wherein one respondent commented..."Mighty pricey for a common coin". There was also some mention made of the "shake and bake" guys. Well folks, I just sold this coin to a respected and knowledgeable dealer for $7,500!!! I guess it wasn't so OVERPRICED afterall. Following is a link to the image of the coin in question: http://www.numisvision.com/gallery/displayimage.php?album=9&pos=0
Mikey
Mikey
DE FALCO NUMISMATIC CONSULTING
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
0
Comments
<< <i>This is a follow up to a thread started by dizzyfoxx in late March of this year wherein one respondent commented..."Mighty pricey for a common coin". There was also some mention made of the "shake and bake" guys. Well folks, I just sold this coin to a respected and knowledgeable dealer for $7,500!!! I guess it wasn't so OVERPRICED afterall. Following is a link to the image of the coin in question: http://www.numisvision.com/gallery/displayimage.php?album=9&pos=0
Mikey >>
Fine and dandy, Mike. But, this doesn't really prove anything, does it?
some coins and get them on FleaBay! People are going quite crazy over rainbows these days.
Perhaps I'll become known as Thomas Coinkade - Coin Painter of Light!
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought.
<< <i>Mike,
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought. >>
It's a little odd to state it as he did, but he could just as easily have the sale price listed and then have Sold next to it. Same difference.
<< <i>
<< <i>Mike,
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought. >>
It's a little odd to state it as he did, but he could just as easily have the sale price listed and then have Sold next to it. Same difference. >>
I don't think so. If it is listed on a website at 'X' amount with a sold tag next to it, that doesn't neccessarily mean it was sold at that seller's asking price. It just means that it is now sold. Anyone seeing that would know what the original seller was asking but would not know how much it actually sold for.
<< <i>Well folks, I just sold this coin to a respected and knowledgeable dealer for $7,500!!! >>
Well, I consider myself a very knowledgeable collector in this series and I personally wouldn't pay $200 for it. Based SOLELY on the image, this coin suggests artificial toning.
I will admit, seeing it in-hand may give me reason to think otherwise. But I've looked at thousands of mint state Buffalo nickels and the toning on this coin (based on the image) just isn't right.
I'm happy to see everything worked out for you and I especially hope the buyer doesn't get stuck with a bodybag trying to get the coin in a 68 holder.
<< <i>Mike,
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought. >>
Brandon: I told him/her that I wanted to do this and he/she was fine with it as long as I didn't name him/her. I've been in this business a long time and certainly wouldn't have posted this information without permission. BTW, there's a PM function on this forum -- just a thought.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i> I guess it wasn't so OVERPRICED after all. >>
coingame2000, OK I'll bite. With respect (and you know I mean this) Just because a "respected and knowledgeable dealer" bought the thing
doesn't really mean it was worth the price, Real, Memorex, or whatever. I believe it is common knowledge (at least I hope so) that many dealers
will step up and buy this sort of thing. Here are a few of my opinions why...... Yes they like it, they like to have a show piece for their cases at shows,
they like to attract attention and also to their websites
And they can afford to do all of the above listed things and hold it for a while for just that, the attention. I'm not passing judgment either way as my worthless opinion means nothing. No doubt the buyer could be reading this, and I'm OK with it.
<< <i>
<< <i>Mike,
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought. >>
Brandon: I told him/her that I wanted to do this and he/she was fine with it as long as I didn't name him/her. I've been in this business a long time and certainly wouldn't have posted this information without permission. BTW, there's a PM function on this forum -- just a thought.
Mikey >>
I am well aware of the PM function. I just thought I would point it out and give you the opportunity to clarify to those who were thinking the same thing as I was that publicly stating the price you sold it to the other dealer for was explicitly permitted by the buyer of the coin.
<< <i>
<< <i>This is a follow up to a thread started by dizzyfoxx in late March of this year wherein one respondent commented..."Mighty pricey for a common coin". There was also some mention made of the "shake and bake" guys. Well folks, I just sold this coin to a respected and knowledgeable dealer for $7,500!!! I guess it wasn't so OVERPRICED afterall. Following is a link to the image of the coin in question: http://www.numisvision.com/gallery/displayimage.php?album=9&pos=0
Mikey >>
Fine and dandy, Mike. But, this doesn't really prove anything, does it? >>
It proves that I'm not the only certifiably crazy
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
And, if this one looks the same in person as it does in the images, you surely realize, that even if the color is original, it looks quite unusual and at least somewhat suspect. So, my question is - what is it about the coin and its toning that caused you and the dealer who bought it to believe the color is original?
Please don't take my post to mean that I'm implying the toning is artificial - I can't tell if it is or not. But, perhaps this thread could be used as a basis for an an informed discussion (maybe even a flame-free one) about toning.
It's not at all uncommon to see a colorfully toned, yet suspect coin get kicked around from one dealer to another before it finally finds a buyer. Right now I'm thinking of a colorfully toned Buffalo nickel that passed through the inventories of three VERY respected dealers over the last 6 months that just recently disappeared again. I wonder if somebody finally took it off the market?
<< <i>Mike, as "young" as you are, I'm guessing that you've still seen quite a few toned Buffalo nickels over the years.
And, if this one looks the same in person as it does in the images, you surely realize, that even if the color is original, it looks quite unusual and at least somewhat suspect. So, my question is - what is it about the coin and its toning that caused you and the dealer who bought it to believe the color is original?
Please don't take my post to mean that I'm implying the toning is artificial - I can't tell if it is or not. But, perhaps this thread could be used as a basis for an an informed discussion (maybe even a flame-free one) about toning. >>
Mark: Thanks for the "young" comment -- you've just risen to the top of my good guy list.
In regard to the 1938-D Buffalo Nickel, I'll be the first to admit that the colors in the image aren't 100% true to the coin itself so you'd definitely have to see it in hand (BTW, this was the only coin on our website that we did NOT image ourselves). Having said that, scores of people (both collectors and dealers alike) have seen the coin in hand and unanimously agree as to the originality of the toning. Moreover, I bought a complete set of mint state Buffalo Nickels from Glendora Coins in 1976 that had been stored in a Library of Coins album for many years. All of the coins were quite beautifully toned and a few were strikingly similar to the 1938-D in question here -- particularly the 1914-S, which is eternally etched in my memory. Both myself and the buyer agreed that this was the most spectacular toned Buffalo Nickel that either of us had ever seen. It had an ethereal quality that resonated the look and feel of real.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i>I saw that coin at the San Francisco ANA show last year and it caused me to laugh out loud. >>
I take back my previous statement -- apparenty we have a dissenter (although I don't recall showing him the coin at the ANA and I can't seem to remember an outburst of laughter). Oh well, I'm getting old and may have had a senior moment.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Mike,
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought. >>
Brandon: I told him/her that I wanted to do this and he/she was fine with it as long as I didn't name him/her. I've been in this business a long time and certainly wouldn't have posted this information without permission. BTW, there's a PM function on this forum -- just a thought.
Mikey >>
I am well aware of the PM function. I just thought I would point it out and give you the opportunity to clarify to those who were thinking the same thing as I was that publicly stating the price you sold it to the other dealer for was explicitly permitted by the buyer of the coin. >>
Brandon: Have you been taking your meds? You seem a bit sensitive.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Mike,
Do you think the dealer you sold it to appreciates you telling everyone what you sold it to him/her for? Just a thought. >>
Brandon: I told him/her that I wanted to do this and he/she was fine with it as long as I didn't name him/her. I've been in this business a long time and certainly wouldn't have posted this information without permission. BTW, there's a PM function on this forum -- just a thought.
Mikey >>
I am well aware of the PM function. I just thought I would point it out and give you the opportunity to clarify to those who were thinking the same thing as I was that publicly stating the price you sold it to the other dealer for was explicitly permitted by the buyer of the coin. >>
Brandon: Have you been taking your meds? You seem a bit sensitive.
Mikey
Sorry, should I add a
<< <i>Mikey, If it wasn't overpriced, why did it take so long to sell? Also, didn't the coin have a higher price on the website? Just wondering...Mike >>
MikeInFL: Yes, it was priced at $7,950 on the website. In the overall scheme of things a PCGS MS67 1938-D Buffalo Nickel IS overpriced at $7,950 but this particular specimen was not your average garden variety -- it was a very special (if not unique) example of this date. Moreover, it was undergraded and will someday end up in the holder it deserves. Why, did it take so long to sell? Because most coin buyers would not recognize the ethereal qualites and potential this coin offered. To be quite frank I was a little sad to see it go -- but I replaced it with another OVERPRICED jewel -- a PCGS PR68 CAMEO 1880 Morgan Dollar that is second to NONE!!!
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i>I just checked out your web site & you need to really back off of the saturation in Photoshop. Talk about 'juiced' photos and saturation overload.....
mfcobra: Maybe you should see the coins in hand before making such a statement. A number of forum members buy coins from me and can attest to the accuracy of the images presented on my website. Did it ever occur to you that I may specialize in spectacular mind blowing toned coins that actually do look like the images? Just come to my table at the next coin show I'm set up at and see for yourself. I've had numerous naysayers eat their words when they saw the coins in hand.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
If you had it on your website for 7950 and marked it as sold.....it doesn't take too many firing neurons to surmise that you probably got somewhere near that for the coin.
no offense but mark me up as another one that doesn't care for the coin.
<< <i>
<< <i>I just checked out your web site & you need to really back off of the saturation in Photoshop. Talk about 'juiced' photos and saturation overload.....
mfcobra: Maybe you should see the coins in hand before making such a statement. A number of forum members buy coins from me and can attest to the accuracy of the images presented on my website. Did it ever occur to you that I may specialize in spectacular mind blowing toned coins that actually do look like the images? Just come to my table at the next coin show I'm set up at and see for yourself. I've had numerous naysayers eat their words when they saw the coins in hand.
Mikey
You really do have to see the coins in-hand to realize how mindblowing they are.
Oh come on. All it proves is that there was one person willing to pay that for it. One sell/buy doesnt make the market.
David
<< <i>Maybe you should see the coins in hand before making such a statement >>
Are you trying to tell me this coin didn't have a little saturation juice added in photoshop??
<< <i>
<< <i>Maybe you should see the coins in hand before making such a statement >>
Are you trying to tell me this coin didn't have a little saturation juice added in photoshop??
I did get a chance to see many of the Battle Creek coins in hand, of which the above coin was one of the finest.
Believe it or not, the colors are so saturated on some of these puppies that the image is representative of the coin.
JMHO, after seeing it in hand.
I'd say market acceptable toning. NT? Maybe.
"Bongo hurtles along the rain soaked highway of life on underinflated bald retread tires."
~Wayne
<< <i>I have seen MANY battlecreek Morgans in hand, and have owned several. None of them have bright lime green that stick out like freakin neon sign. Granted they have beautiful colors and are some of the nicest toned Morgans available. When I see a juiced photo I know it, because they look like a neon sign rather than a toned Morgan. >>
Maybe that you have not seen the right ones
I realize that toned coins are hard to image, and since I haven't seen the coin in person, I won't comment further on the coin itself.
I have a 38 D in a PC 7 holder. Mark Feld knows the coin. It has bold and beautiful gold rim toning with powder blue centers on both sides. The coin is a head-turner, but I can't see getting anywhere near $7,500 for it. Probably closer to $300 on a good day.
However, just because a respected dealer buys a particular coin, this doesn't necessarily means he / she knows how to grade the coin, or even if he / she does (know how to grade it), it doesn't mean that he / she is "buying it right." We've both seen plenty of instances of respected dealers paying way too strong money for particular coins. I could list over ten examples of this from the last Long Beach Show alone.
I realize that some people out there 'must' have a particular coin and will pay what to others may appear to be obscene money for it. To each his own; I am very liberal about things that don't affect me personally.
"Seu cabra da peste,
"Sou Mangueira......."
<< <i>I have seen MANY battlecreek Morgans in hand, and have owned several. None of them have bright lime green that stick out like freakin neon sign. Granted they have beautiful colors and are some of the nicest toned Morgans available. When I see a juiced photo I know it, because they look like a neon sign rather than a toned Morgan. >>
As fountainheadgold said -- "maybe you have not seen the right ones". The fact is I was the top buyer in the Battle Creek auctions and acquired virtually all the FINEST coins (103 of the very best specimens to be exact). You may have seen many Battle Creek Morgan's in hand -- but I bet they weren't the top tier pieces (and there is a GIGANTIC difference). You may have owned several but I'm quite confident that they were not top tier specimens either because I bought 'em all and didn't sell any to you. Moreover, I saw the entire deal intact before they were sold in auction and tendered an offer for the collection -- so I am intimately familiar with the complete contents. At least two dozen of the coins I bought are mind boggling glow-in-the-dark neon monsters that are so bright, saturated and flourescent that they literally take your breath away. Somehow I don't think you've experienced these coins firsthand so your comments have no real basis in fact.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i> I guess it wasn't so OVERPRICED afterall.
Oh come on. All it proves is that there was one person willing to pay that for it. One sell/buy doesnt make the market.
David >>
David: I never said or implied that this transaction made the market. I wasn't speaking in generalities -- I was refering to the fact that this particular specimen wasn't so OVERPRICED and obviously it wasn't!!
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***
<< <i>
<< <i>Maybe you should see the coins in hand before making such a statement >>
Are you trying to tell me this coin didn't have a little saturation juice added in photoshop??
That is not what I am trying to tell you. What I did say was that your really have to see the coins in-hand and compare them to the photographs, not just what you percieve to be an accurate portrayal of the coins. I guarantee you that if you held one of the photographs up next to the coins and compare the colors in-hand, they would not be that far off. I take it that Mike uses a scanner to image his coins that gives them a strange "glow" effect which is common on photos done with a scanner, however, the colors are usually pretty close to what they actually are in-hand. Don't confuse that strange glow effect to oversaturation. It's just the way they were imaged and the black background makes it jump even more.
<< <i>As fountainheadgold said -- "maybe you have not seen the right ones". The fact is I was the top buyer in the Battle Creek auctions and acquired virtually all the FINEST coins (103 of the very best specimens to be exact). You may have seen many Battle Creek Morgan's in hand -- but I bet they weren't the top tier pieces (and there is a GIGANTIC difference). You may have owned several but I'm quite confident that they were not top tier specimens either because I bought 'em all and didn't sell any to you. Moreover, I saw the entire deal intact before they were sold in auction and tendered an offer for the collection -- so I am intimately familiar with the complete contents. At least two dozen of the coins I bought are mind boggling glow-in-the-dark neon monsters that are so bright, saturated and flourescent that they literally take your breath away. Somehow I don't think you've experienced these coins firsthand so your comments have no real basis in fact. >>
If you are such a big time player, why are all of your photos blurry and completely void of any detail? If you are such a big time player, why don't you stop bragging about yourself and higher someone that knows how to photograph coins!
<< <i>That is not what I am trying to tell you. What I did say was that your really have to see the coins in-hand and compare them to the photographs, not just what you percieve to be an accurate portrayal of the coins. I guarantee you that if you held one of the photographs up next to the coins and compare the colors in-hand, they would not be that far off. I take it that Mike uses a scanner to image his coins that gives them a strange "glow" effect which is common on photos done with a scanner, however, the colors are usually pretty close to what they actually are in-hand. Don't confuse that strange glow effect to oversaturation. It's just the way they were imaged and the black background makes it jump even more. >>
I wasn't questioning the coins quality, I was stating that his photographs are suspect and appear juiced. So if someone can post a real large pixel image with a decent camera equipped with a macro lens, I woud LOVE to compare that photo w/ the previous one I posted.
Nothing even comes close. Nothing.
You could blow up on Photoshop and still not capture the wild neon glow of these coins.
Those that have seen will testify to this. The Golden Boys that haven't witnessed these stunners will continue to mock and show continued distain as they've done so in this lively thread.
Once a viewer, always a believer.
<< <i>
<< <i>As fountainheadgold said -- "maybe you have not seen the right ones". The fact is I was the top buyer in the Battle Creek auctions and acquired virtually all the FINEST coins (103 of the very best specimens to be exact). You may have seen many Battle Creek Morgan's in hand -- but I bet they weren't the top tier pieces (and there is a GIGANTIC difference). You may have owned several but I'm quite confident that they were not top tier specimens either because I bought 'em all and didn't sell any to you. Moreover, I saw the entire deal intact before they were sold in auction and tendered an offer for the collection -- so I am intimately familiar with the complete contents. At least two dozen of the coins I bought are mind boggling glow-in-the-dark neon monsters that are so bright, saturated and flourescent that they literally take your breath away. Somehow I don't think you've experienced these coins firsthand so your comments have no real basis in fact. >>
If you are such a big time player, why are all of your photos blurry and completely void of any detail? If you are such a big time player, why don't you stop bragging about yourself and higher someone that knows how to photograph coins!
That was quite a mature post. It's pretty obvious that you have nothing of substance to contribute.
<< <i>That was quite a mature post. It's pretty obvious that you have nothing of substance to contribute. >>
It's entirely laughable that the people who keep chiming and and attempting to defend these photos happen to have super juiced images themselves
<< <i>
<< <i>That was quite a mature post. It's pretty obvious that you have nothing of substance to contribute. >>
It's entirely laughable that the people who keep chiming and and attempting to defend these photos happen to have super juiced images themselves >>
Alright! the little troll is nibbling on my ankles now! Everyone here knows our images aren't juiced. It's really too bad you don't have a clue what nice coins look like in person.
<< <i>Alright! the little troll is nibbling on my ankles now! Everyone here knows our images aren't juiced. It's really too bad you don't have a clue what nice coins look like in person. >>
Well said. There are at least 10 posters on this board that have seen this coingame2000's coins in person and attest that the photos are not juiced. But go ahead, iceman, keep battling those windmills.
<< <i>
<< <i>As fountainheadgold said -- "maybe you have not seen the right ones". The fact is I was the top buyer in the Battle Creek auctions and acquired virtually all the FINEST coins (103 of the very best specimens to be exact). You may have seen many Battle Creek Morgan's in hand -- but I bet they weren't the top tier pieces (and there is a GIGANTIC difference). You may have owned several but I'm quite confident that they were not top tier specimens either because I bought 'em all and didn't sell any to you. Moreover, I saw the entire deal intact before they were sold in auction and tendered an offer for the collection -- so I am intimately familiar with the complete contents. At least two dozen of the coins I bought are mind boggling glow-in-the-dark neon monsters that are so bright, saturated and flourescent that they literally take your breath away. Somehow I don't think you've experienced these coins firsthand so your comments have no real basis in fact. >>
If you are such a big time player, why are all of your photos blurry and completely void of any detail? If you are such a big time player, why don't you stop bragging about yourself and higher someone that knows how to photograph coins!
I sincerely feel compassion for you and just lifted you up in prayer. It so very sad to see a fellow human being filled with so much venom and rage. I pray that you will soon be delivered from whatever is troubling you.
Mikey
Visit Our Website @ www.numisvision.com
Specializing in DMPL Dollars, MONSTER toners and other Premium Quality U.S. Coins
*** Visit Mike De Falco's NEW Coin Talk Blog! ***