Options
Multi-stage Atlanta Show Report, April 6-7, 2006
I am not ready for the full show report yet, but I will file this brief report and fill in the rest when I get home tomorrow.
I viewed the Heritage lots yesteday, and the Duke's Creek coins ranged from nice to fabulous. I was hoping to like Lot 1489 (1857-D G $1 in MS-62 ex-Eliasberg), and the coin did not disappoint. Outside the Duke's Creek collection, other than the Stella, most of the rest of the gold in the Heritage sale was dipped, ugly, or both. The $150,000 1798 $2.5 was hideous. There were some nice ciculated Charlotte gold coins in the F-XF range which were nice and original.
Today, the show was bustling. A lot of schools are on spring break here, so quite a few families were present, always nice to see. Dealers ranged from having a good (but not great) show to below average. Grading was tight at NGC and PCGS (I have first-hand experience
)., so too few new coins were "made" (
).
Lunch with forum members FatMan, Tootawl, Cmanbb (or whatever Larry's forum handle is), Trinketts, Tassa, Jaywalker, and Die Varieties was fun. Everyone passed their newps around, and I saw a lot of really cool coins. FatMan stole the show. I will let him report his newp if he chooses, but suffice to say, it is a super cool coin, and he might be changing his icon soon!
RYK bought Lot 1489
and a few others, sold what he needed to sell at good prices, bought coins for his children and the new ANA Journall for Mrs. RYK..
It's late, I will post more if and when I return tomorrow.
I viewed the Heritage lots yesteday, and the Duke's Creek coins ranged from nice to fabulous. I was hoping to like Lot 1489 (1857-D G $1 in MS-62 ex-Eliasberg), and the coin did not disappoint. Outside the Duke's Creek collection, other than the Stella, most of the rest of the gold in the Heritage sale was dipped, ugly, or both. The $150,000 1798 $2.5 was hideous. There were some nice ciculated Charlotte gold coins in the F-XF range which were nice and original.
Today, the show was bustling. A lot of schools are on spring break here, so quite a few families were present, always nice to see. Dealers ranged from having a good (but not great) show to below average. Grading was tight at NGC and PCGS (I have first-hand experience
Lunch with forum members FatMan, Tootawl, Cmanbb (or whatever Larry's forum handle is), Trinketts, Tassa, Jaywalker, and Die Varieties was fun. Everyone passed their newps around, and I saw a lot of really cool coins. FatMan stole the show. I will let him report his newp if he chooses, but suffice to say, it is a super cool coin, and he might be changing his icon soon!
RYK bought Lot 1489
It's late, I will post more if and when I return tomorrow.
0
Comments
Is it too early to start talking about Columbus
I'll have to make the rounds tomorrow!
So, did someone buy the hideous quarter eagle for 150K?
Jerry
On Thursday night at the Heritage sale, there were some interesting occurences surrounding lot #666. First, the auctioneer announced that he coin was not the rare variety as was listed in the catalog. Then, about ten lots later, a floor bidder/dealer claimed that that he did not have the opporunity to raise the bid to $8500 (coin closed at $8000, to the book). After a somewhat heated exchange, between the dealer and the auctioneer, a man in the audience identified himself as the consignor and said that he want to reopen the lot for bidding because he felt that he was shortchanged. After more heated exchange, Heritage stuck to their guns and would not reopen the lot.
Another interesting Heritage moment was when I overheard a dealer ask a Heritage rep who bought a coin so that he could try to buy the coin from that buyer. I would have assumed that there is some degree of privacy for such things but apparenty not.
I also learned from a little birdie (who flies here
Finally, for now, there are three Dahlonga $5's left for my date set, and the toughest date remaining is the 1858-D. Much to my surprise, there was a pretty nice one at the John Schuch (Faiirtraderz) table. To be continued...
<< <i>Lot 1489 (1857-D G $1 in MS-62 ex-Eliasberg), >>
Can't wait to see this one. One day I'll own a lesser example for my Registry Set.
<< <i>there was a pretty nice one at the John Schuch (Faiirtraderz) table >>
Sounds like a good time!
I'm waiting to hear the rest of this one!
The first person I saw at the show on Thursday was Legend/Laura. It is always a pleasure to visit with Laura--guys, with how many women can you talk intelligently about coins AND football? Anyways, on Friday, Laura paid very strong money to buy a coin back from me, no fuss, no muss. If it was only this easy to sell to all dealers!
The second person I saw on Thursday was FatMan. I kinda feel like I spent the whole show with him (in a good way
I spent some time with Ron (Newnmismatist) and Rick (RKKay). This was the first show in which I met Ron face-to-face, and he was as insightful and scholarly in person as he is here on the boards. If anyone is looking for a collecting mentor, especially but not exclusive to the area of proof IHCs and toned coins, Ron would be great to meet and learn from. I learned more about toned coins in 30 minutes with Ron today than 3 years on the forum.
JadeRareCoins (Dennis) and Tassa (Daneca) had a nice selection of collector-grade, mostly 19th century material, which was clearly selling quite nicely. I almost pulled the trigger on an 1806 F-12 25c with a cool die crack and an appearance that STman would certainly approve. Alas, I was overspent and knew of another big coin which might be waiting for me in the wings, so I passed. Some forum member would definitely be happy with it. Dennis also informs me that his website is operational.
Though new coins were not being made (I was 0 for 6 in my submissions at NGC), I was able to efficiently get my auction coin, the Duke's Creek 1857-D NGC MS-62 quickly crossed to an Eliasberg 1857-D PCGS MS-62. The folks at the PCGS table were unusually nice and helpful, and I even think they charged be less than they were supposed to. The coin was back to me in under 2 1/2 hours!
Naturally, I spent the most time at the Gold Rush Gallery table where Doug Winter was also set up. Things seemed pretty busy for the Gold Rush Gallery team, and between deals, I was able to learn collecting pearls and see killer coins, courtesy of "Dahlonega". We discussed the Duke's Creek auction, which despite the fact that some of the coins had been processed
Forum member Jaywalker was adding generic gold to his collection at an alarming clip, hunting down Liberty $10's and snapping up a Heritage auction 1904 $20 PCGS MS-64, which looked nicer than most 65s on the bourse. One annoying dealer thing happenned when Jaywalker was inspecting the 1862 G$1 MS-63 that he ended up buying: first, when he asked to look at the coin again, the dealer asked snidely if he was here to romance it or take it home (or something to that effect). Then, when I asked if I could look at the 1932 $10's PCGS MS-63, he handed me one from the stack of three or four and would not let me see the others. Pass, now and forever!
That's all for now. I am home safe and sound (no catastrophies, Longacre). Barry, I did not buy the 1858-D $5 from John Schuch. I had an expert look at it, and he thought that the coin had been tooled on the reverse--a PCGS-graded coin--can you imagine?????
Here's the Heritage photos of my new coin:
P.S. It would never occur to me that the name Sweet Water (all one word) would be a forbidden word.
J
siliconvalleycoins.com
Had a brief encounter with ex-forum member
I have never seen more steady public attendance at a large coin show than I saw today. Kudos to RKKay, Julian, and others for volunteering for the YN treasure hunt.
Regulated showed me some of the coolest coins I have ever seen today.
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
I see no problem with Sweetwater?
Congratulations on your new gold dollar, it does look quite nice.
Tom
me too, why?????
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
My 1866 Philly Mint Set
Actually, the Heritage photo is pretty dead-on. They obviously spent more time than usual with the Duke's Creek consignment, as most of these photos were high-quality and realistic. Not so for the Dahlonega coin in the general auction. The copper spot above the one in the date on the reverse is easily seen in the 1982 Eliasberg catalog photo. The cool pedigree was certainly an attraction, and I will enjoy tracking down Mehl's Rawson collection auction catalog from 1922 as a companion for the piece:
Ex: Rawson Collection (BMM, 11/22); John Clapp Sr.; John Clapp Jr; Eliasberg Collection (Bowers and Ruddy, 10/82), lot 36; Hankock and Harwell; Georgia Collection; Leon Farmer Collection; Hankock and Harwell. This is the plate coin in the first edition of Doug Winter's book Gold Coins of the Dahlonega Mint, 1838-1861.
So,,,,who's going to Co. this summer.....
<< <i>Great coin - congrats. Thanks for the show report. Sounds like I should have somehow found the time to get there.......
So,,,,who's going to Co. this summer.....
I'll be there.
That Duke's Creek dollar looks fantastic. Congrats. I really like gold dollars, and that has great eye appeal (even for a Heritage picture). Great insights into the show, and it is great to hear that your travels were "uneventful".
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
I'll be taking the early gold varieties class with JD during first week - I think Mr Eureka will be there too... If anyone hasn't done ANA Summer Seminar and is wondering whether it is worthwhile, STOP PROCRASTINATING AND GET SIGNED UP!!!! You will not regret it. I promise.
What is now proved was once only imagined. - William Blake