So.. would you consider this AT or not?

p8nt

After you have decided if it is AT or not... click here.

Craton

Top pic screams AT.

Hadleydog

Top pic with the funky purple looks at.

DenverDave

From the bottom photos, looks NT to me...

Edited to Add... Did not see the "click here" on the bottom of your post p8nt...

There the same coin in the two sets of photos you posted correct...? the top set is just enhanced...?

You have this coin in hand...?

In any event, guilt by association to say the least..."-(

LucyBop

I would have to see it in person...

Coxe

Without seeing them in person, I would think they are both suspect with the first one highly suspect. I'd be very surprised it the first was natural and think they are both AT.

CTcollector

without a doubt - AT

BAJJERFAN

Guy musta got real lucky and found a bag a mixed silver coins ALL toned the same 2 colors red n yeller!! especially nice to find those 1921's in there.

kryptonitecomics

AT as heck....folks this is a no brainer....as mentioned above....every coin he sells has the same toning pattern and colors and this joker has been discussed her at length numerous times.

Save your money and make your own if you want pretty colors on common silver.

TorinoCobra71

The top one most likely the bottom one, can tell for sure.....

TorinoCobra71

fountainheadgold

<< <i>AT as heck....folks this is a no brainer....as mentioned above....every coin he sells has the same toning pattern and colors and this joker has been discussed her at length numerous times.

Save your money and make your own if you want pretty colors on common silver. >>





I agree

NumisOxide

AT all the way. Yep, that seller does have a lot of coins with similiar toning.

FatMan

AT all day

rainbowroosie

I would not purchase the coin.

p8nt

Im not planning on buying it. I saw a coin of his and it didnt scream AT to me. I happened to click on another coin and it was his with the same pattern and colors... thats when I investigated his coins he sells and determined them to be AT.

I was planning on buying it as NT until I saw the rest.

BAJJERFAN

It doesn't look like he wants outrageous prices for his AToners so maybe buyin one or two and sendin them to a slabber mite not be such a bad idea. At least you won't go broke tryin and the coin can always serve as a reminder to be more discriminating.

Here is a AToner that got by.

Hadleydog

It doesn't look like he wants outrageous prices for his AToners so maybe buyin one or two and sendin them to a slabber mite not be such a bad idea. At least you won't go broke tryin and the coin can always serve as a reminder to be more discriminating
Actually, the guys not so bad as his work is. Nor does he claim they are natural. Last time I conversed with him, he told me to 'buy coin- be happy..........if don't like, send back and be happy'. No, can't get mad at him.
Bajjerfan, why spend the money on a body-bag?

BAJJERFAN

<< <i>Bajjerfan, why spend the money on a body-bag? >>



Because maybe they wouldn't BB it. Afterall NGC did slab that 2 sided toner I posted.

Myqqy

Last time I conversed with him, he told me to 'buy coin- be happy..........if don't like, send back and be happy'. No, can't get mad at him.

Sorry, but "don't worry, be happy" bullcrap doesn't excuse AT damage to coins, or newbies getting suckered out of money....

kryptonitecomics

I agree with Myggy...

If you know the coin is AT and decide it's worth the dough...no problem. There are plenty of folks getting ripped and not even knowing it, which is why I have a problem with the seller. He may not say they are natural...but is he stating the coins are Artificially toned....if not that he is a criminal in my humble opinion.

I have sold two AT coins on ebay in the last week.....I knew they were even though they looked pretty...and I clearly stated they were so that buyers could make an educated buying choice

This guy is making the coins himself or knows who is so he can't say he doesn't know there not legit.

Hadleydog

Sorry, but "don't worry, be happy" bullcrap doesn't excuse AT damage to coins, or newbies getting suckered out of money....
Yes, you are absolutely right. I was writing to him because I wanted him to disclose the fact all his offering were at.
The fact is I couldn't get angry with him like I have in the past when I have 'asked the question' to other Dr's, he just kept being so damn pleasant.

tsacch

AT

mozin

No brainer, AT all the way.