A problem with a MadMarty transaction

WorldTypeSet

Yup, didn't think it would happen, but I have a problem with the Mad One relating to the purchase of thisset and a few other coins. I followed all the rules, and MadMarty didn't play fair. I made an offer, he accepted, we both said "Done Deal", and I sent him my payment.

The coins arrived, and what has he done? He sent me 5 extra coins, as follows:
- Canada 1954 5c NGC PL66
- Canada 2003 5c PCGS PR68DCAM
- Canada 2003 5c PCGS PR68DCAM
- Canada 1953-2003 Coronation 5c PCGS PR69DCAM
- Canada 1967 5c broadstrike NGC bodybag - improper cleaning

Now, I'm not sure what to do, and need advice.

jscovill

Mad Marty is afterall "MAD" but if he did it on purpose, you could just pass on the generosity and give one or 2 away if it would make you feel better. If he did it on accident then by all means, make a fair offer if you want the coins.

Clankeye

<< <i>Now, I'm not sure what to do, and need advice. >>



Make him buy them back from you for twice what you paid for them!!!!!!

Ummm... wait...

MadMarty is madder than a really mad guy. His generosity is crazy bad.

WorldTypeSet

Mad Marty is afterall "MAD" but if he did it on purpose, you could just pass on the generosity and give one or 2 away if it would make you feel better

He did it on purpose, that sneaky fellow. The coins he sent aren't candidates for a giveaway, but I could pass on the generosity by having a giveaway of my own. I'll add that as an option to the Poll.

trozau

Unacceptable! Off with his head!

cosmicdebris

Geez he sent you extra coins!!! He sent me dinner

Numismatics

How about leave him a "negative feedback"?

LOL

docday2003

definitely have a giveaway. Please enter my name....

AuldFartte

Such "madness" is indeed a rare thing nowdays ... enjoy it while it still exists

WorldTypeSet

Well, it looks like the masses have spoken. I'll search through my stuff this week to find something suitable for the "Mad Marty is a generous guy" giveaway.