Newer Silver Proof Sets

jsturman31

I am new to coin collecting and I see alot of these newer proof sets like 1999 silver sets where the coins are toned ( I guess toned, bronze patches/tint to some areas). Does being discolored like that bring down the price to the point I should avoid collecting them or would it be to my favor in the long run as I think it adds some eye appeal as I see you guys referring to.

Jj

Btw I am new, and hope to be around for a while

TorinoCobra71

to the forums. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Some toning is appealing and some arent.

Regards,

TorinoCobra71

BillJones

Unfortunately some sets have toned in the mint holders from whatever reason(s). Sometimes it has to do with improper storage. Other times it is believed that the mint packages have problems with them that cause the coins to tone.

Does the toning raise or lower the value of the sets?

If you get lucky and get great toning, you could sell the coins for big bucks to people who are ga-ga over toning.

BUT ...

Usually the coins tone ugly and are worth less, usually quite a bit less.

It's all in the luck of the draw, and usually the draw is bad when these sets tone in the mint issued holders.

Myqqy

It really depends on the type of toning, the colors involved, the placement, etc. If you're looking at the coins, and think "holy crap, that's beautiful", then chances are other people will say similar things. You first need to understand yourself and your tastes- do you prefer white coins? Do you like color? Only certain colors, or certain patterns? After looking at many toned sets or coins, you will begin to understand what brings a premium, and what doesn't. And then there is the whole AT/NT issue!

Woodwind

Hello and welcome aboard.

Good advice from others so far which I'll take a step further.

Typically, if the coin reflects rainbow-like colors, whether red, blue, green, or some combination thereof, it could command more $$ for buyers interested in toned coins. If it's more of a dull color like brown or grey, it could very well lower the values.

Be careful of state quarters that my look a little too colorful or vibrant. They may be artificially toned, or AT. If you're concerned about future resale value, you will want to educate yourself as to tell the difference between an artificially toned coin, or natrually toned, (NT) coin. AT vs NT is not an exact science yet as you will see if you spend any amount of time on this forum.

Chances are that if a state quarter is already in a PCGS or NGC holder, it's naturally toned and "market acceptable." However, be aware that sellers will frequently charge much more than what a non-toned example would bring, so this is something you would need to educate yourself on and determine if you feel it's really worth the extra premium.

Again, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, so if you see something you think you would enjoy having in your collection, enjoy. Good luck.

DorkGirl

cladking

Welcome aboard.

Some date mint and proof sets tone or tarnish very quickly. It's a good idea to keep a
close eye on these to stop the process if it starts. All 1968 cents have at least small
carbon spots now and about 95% have massive ugly spotting.

wam98