How do old ANACS slabs do at crossing to PCGS?

CardsFan

In general how well are old ANACS slabe graded? The ones that are slightly smaller then today's ANACS some with barcodes some without.

Peaceman

Usually on for Peace $.... I've crossed 2 for 2 this year.

ajc

I only submitted on for crossover and it crossed the same grade.

Punscoins

I had one CC morgan cross, but I don't know how to tell if it was old holder or not.

And by the way, this was almost 2 years ago.

Marc Vetsch

fcloud

I sent my 1938 D/S Buffalo for cross it went from ANACS 65 to PCGS 66. All the others I have broken out. Each went at least the original grade and some have gone up a point.

jcping

For standing liberty quarters, I hand picked 7 and I am 7 of 7 crossed with one upgrade

MFH

90% of my Barbers that were in ANACS holders crossed at the same grade, a few bumped up a point or so. Only a couple DNC because I set the bar too high. Only a couple were downgraded, again by only a point or so.

I received better treatment on the ANACS cross-overs than I did on the NGC cross-overs !

jonesy

I sent a gorgeous 1957 ANACS MS66FS to PCGS and it came back as a 65FS.

DRUNNER

Posted these results a while ago . . . all cracked and sent in raw.

Lincolns . . . all 1st gen. holders:

1914-D ANACS VF-35 to PCGS XF40.
1922-No "D" Strong Reverse VF-35 to PCGS XF40.
1909-S VDB ANACS MS64RD to PCGS MS64RD.

I was a happy camper . . . and wish I had a few more . .

DRUNNER