My first Classic Commem - Guess the grade - Grade revealed in last post

Cladiator

Shouldn't really be buying right now but what they heck! I've really taken a liking to the classic commems lately and this is my first one. What do you all think about its overall look and take a stab at it's grade. It's in PCGS plastic, I'll post the grade later on.

mgoodm3

64

RGT

I wouldn't go higher than MS63.

I forgot to say, it looks like good luster and no ugly toning. Overall, a nice look.

LeeG

Nice One!! I'm thinking 65/66?

NgokLi

I would say no higher than 63

midwestcoin13

MS63

lordmarcovan

Cool.

My gut said 62 but I'll bet I'm low.

poorguy

MS63. Nice Long Island.

Mmm, sounds like a good drink right about now.

mozin

I don't even feel comfortable buying slabed coins scrictly relying on a picture. Judging by the picture alone it looks like nice luster for an AU58.

FullHorn

MS64 no I mean 63

lordmarcovan

I would venture a guess that more than 75% had a Columbian half as their first classic commem. Or a BTW or Washington-Carver, maybe. Or a Stone Mountain.

Maybe this calls for a poll...

FullHorn

lordm if you start a poll, include the word cleaned in front of Columbian so I can click the right spot

Cladiator

Wow the guesses sure were all over the board. The grade on the plastic is MS64 and it is blast white (but you can't really tell because of my less than perfect photo skills lol)

FatMan

Nice LI Cladiator. Pic was a little too dark for me to take a stab at the grade but I know how hard it is to image flashy white coins. I was leaning towards MS63 but 64 works for me. Welcome to the wonderful world of commems. I'm still looking for a LI for my set but I've got 27/50. Check out the link below for a collage.

lordmarcovan

I know what the answer is... I know what the answer is... he told me... so nyah nyah.

And I was wrong.

Cladiator

cool coins and cool collage fatman!