SGS Slab MS-70 Cross-Over to PCGS MS-67????

TheRock

Anyone ever had a SGS Slab MS-70 Cross-Over to PCGS MS-67???? This is a supid question since a I know that SGS is not a good grading company, but they can't be that bad. Curious if a MS-70 from SGS would ever grade to a MS-67 PCGS. I would never ask this question on a PROOF, but what about a MS????

kieferscoins

<< <i>but they can't be that bad. >>



Yes they can.

I think you would have a better chance of a proof crossing to PR-67 then a MS one.

Cameron Kiefer

TheRock

Why is that. The PF's seem to be more scrutinized by the graders. I would think theat since eveything from SGS on MS is 69-70 that they would be better suited for a crossgrade from MS70- to MS67?

RotatedRainbows

Probably would be closer to a 57 then a 67.

TheRock

Thanks. 57, do they even grade that LOW??? LOL

LeeG

Good question John! I'd like to see some actually data. Guessing is ok but who knows till some actual results are posted? I might buy, and submit, some SGS so we have some concrete data on this. A few examples won't be exact of course, but it's a start. Some PCI and NTC worked out right. Stay tuned! Lee

kieferscoins

I'd stay away from any SGS slab unless you have it in hand and know how to grade.

Cameron Kiefer

kieferscoins

<< <i>I might buy, and submit, some SGS so we have some concrete data on this. >>



Don't waste your money lee.

Cameron Kiefer

TheRock

I'm at a show in a couple of days. If one shows up, I might just buy it to send in a try. If it works, I'll let everyone know. What a great thread this would make. Dam, Ebay would go NUTS!!!!!!

LeeG

Thanks Cameron! I appreciate you looking out for me and I hear and understand what your saying!! Thanks Again, Lee

GAT

You must be kidding, for the sake of your wallet treat all SGS coins as being raw!