Real or AT? Updated: Grade in!

Tonelover

Thanks in advance for the opinions.



The grade in on 1/17.

1 21839714 Constitut S$1 1987-P USA Artificial Color

Oh well, one of those senior moments I guess.

Myqqy

It looks AT to me......

pursuitofliberty

Wow, tough one ... I have a gut feeling that it's the real deal. The colors look right, as do the varying concentrics, and it seems to lay right (at least from the pictures) ... and also because I can't figure how someone would fake that one.

Either way ... 'tis a pretty coin!

Plus I wanted to post so everyone would see your icon quarter twice

TUMUSS

Knee-jerk was AT....BUT if NT...THAT is one KILLER COIN!

morgannut2

Without a closer image, I'm leaning to NT. If it was stored in that velvet box w/o the plastic cover it might make sense.

wam98

I'm thinking NT because of how smooth the colors blend. If it is AT, it sure is pretty.

tsacch

AT at first glance and AT after a beer............AT after breakfast...........AT...yes, AT

jbsteven

I'm going NT on this one.

fivecents

NT

I sold a proof 1986 Statue of Liberty dollar with rim toning that looked like that except it only had 15% the toning that your commemorative has. I had it graded at PCGS..... PR68 and it sold for $386.00.
Get that puppy in a PCGS holder and you will make some SERIOUS money.

dthigpen

Slab it and I'll bet Anaconda will buy it!

Steve27

I'm bothered by the uniformity of the toning on both sides, but it could be NT.

nwcs

I'm leaning to NT.

kryptonitecomics

NT

Tonelover

I'm glad that the tide is turning towards the answer I want to hear!

It's a coin I just BIN'd on ebay with the full realization that I may end up being the bug instead of the windshield. No pain, no gain as they say. I'll try to report back in a while when I find out whether it grades or not.

I give it a 50-50 shot going from the images, can't really argue strongly either way at this point.

jdimmick

Looks NT to me, the color does not look applied. But if thier is the least bit of uncertainty, then it will probably BB!

rainbowroosie

Blatant AT....someone stuck it in the original plastic to fool you....

poptopsRus

I'd give it a shot and send it in, it might make it

MoneyLA

It looks good. give it a shot at pcgs. cheers, alan mendelson

coinfreak499

NT; toning like that is common if the coin was housed in that case for a long time.

jom

You have to ask yourself if the coin is NT HOW did it get that toning?

AT, IMO.

jom

eagle7

It may be NT, but here is the question. If toning like that is common from being in the original holder for a long period of time, where are all the others that should look like that one. I have not seen them.

1907Quarter

leaning towards steve27's reply on first page...

braddick

<< <i>Blatant AT....someone stuck it in the original plastic to fool you.... >>

tonecoin2003's work, now being sold on the secondary market. Edited to add: I see now you paid close to $300.00 for this one. Is there a return policy?

SUPERCARCOINS

Tonelover .........., what was the bottom line on this piece ?

tsacch

I bet a nickle its body bagged at PCGS

Myqqy

tonecoin2003's work, now being sold on the secondary market.

This is a tonecoin2003 product??