Should I trust PCI in this instance?

FrattLaw

Michael

JadeRareCoin

100% NT (nice, too). Don't know about their grading opinion, however. Is it the old green holder, or the newer gold label?

sliderider

I say it's NT. I have Morgans and Peace dollars that have similar patterns of gold and black toning on them that I know aren't AT because I dipped them when I first got them and all I have done to them since is put them into 2x2's and pack them up in a box and that damn butt ugly toning came right back.

PutTogether

That is completely natural toning.

Steve27

First clue that it's NT, toning is only on the reverse. Second clue that it's NT, it not very nice toning.

fivecents

NT all the way. I bet that is a green label PCI holder and the label in the holder toned the coin.

kieferscoins

I bet they graded it MS-64.

Cameron Kiefer

MadMarty

Who is ever holding the slab for the picture need a manicure.

dorkkarl

please include an option for "mkt-acceptable" in future polls like this!

i did'nt vote, though i think it is m-a tone.

K S

greghansen

That's nice IMO. I like it. Seems very natural to me.

FrattLaw

<< <i>I bet that is a green label PCI holder and the label in the holder toned the coin >>


Actually, its a gold label, and I never considered the whole "label toning" possiblity. But I doubt it since the obverse isn't toned as well.


<< <i>I bet they graded it MS-64. >>


Nope I actually think they got this one right -- MS62. Though it could go MS63 IMHO hard to tell from these pics though.

Michael

RGT

Does the holder have any egg on it?

Stuart

I'm guessing Natural Toning...

magikbilly

<< <i>First clue that it's NT, toning is only on the reverse. >>



Hi,
wasn't there just a big post explaining that this means nothing at all? Didn't Frattlaw just do the post with the AT slabbed silver dollars (acetic acid and sulfur in a plastic bag..)?

Best,
Billy