PCGS say NO, but NGC says YES...

techeff

Should've sent these to NGC first, I guess...

MS64 RB


MS62

WACoinGuy

I like the dime!

Goober

and I like the cent! Did you ever think it may go proof? I have an 89 BRN and that coin looks like a beautiful maroon proof but came back as such. Oh well.

ms70

That dime is really nice!

billboat

Nice coins, nice pics but what was actually said? I'm so confused!!

dorkkarl

assuming your digi-pics are accurate, i do not like the toning on either of those coins.

but of course, that doesn't mean they are mkt-unacceptable.....

K S

Shamika

The dime does look a bit funny.

magikbilly

Hi all,
the dime looks especially funny to me - I collect dimes - perhaps overdip and who knows...? Hard to say from a scan. The penny struck me odd but copper is not my strong point.

Best,
Billy

wingedliberty

Both are gorgeous coins!

Russ

So, PCGS bodybagged that IHC and NGC graded it. Not surprising. PCGS is a bunch of wienies when it comes to toned copper.

Russ, NCNE

EVillageProwler

What were the reasons from PCGS?

jcping

Mmmmmm...... the barber dime color is almost identical to the Barber half in the world grading series round #4. PCGS said it is an AT.

techeff

What were the reasons from PCGS?

I don't remember the exact reasons PCGS gave, but they didn't like the color. I'm glad NGC did.

tradedollarnut

the barber dime color is almost identical to the Barber half in the world grading series round #4. PCGS said it is an AT.

My thoughts exactly. On the cent, NGC probably thought it was safe enough at under $200 to holder it.

dorkkarl

dudes, both those coins are flame-torch jobbies. ngc screwed up!

K S