What do you think of my new seated half??? Grade Posted!

Wisconsin

I just picked this one up and wanted to get some opinions. It is in a PCGS holder and is Mintstate. Nice fully original coin. Spent years in an old manila envelope where it got its attractive toning. I know my pictures did not capture the colors. Obverse lower right is toned in colors of gold and green and the reverse is colored better going from gold to green to red. It is a very original never messed with coin. What do you think PCGS graded it??




PCGS graded this coin a MS63. The subdued luster is the only thing holding it back I would say. It sure is a nice clean coin with nice color when tilted in the light. It's so hard to find them original looking as you all know.

kieferscoins

MS-61.

Cameron Kiefer

Goober

Ooh, I like it. Very nice, I'm going 63 on this baby.

TonedCoinTrader

64!

ms70

That is super nice. I'll go with 64. Look at the obverse shield! You can cut your fingers on it!! The reverse shield
is about as good too!

ziggy29

I'm going to say 63. It looks very sharp and I don't see many flaws...but I also don't see much luster at all. Based on what I see in the picture, if this sucker was fully lustrous it's probably a 65, maybe even a 66. I'm guessing this is a tough one to grade by the picture.

roadrunner

The luster doesn't appear all that strong, esp. on the reverse. You only see it well around the devices. My guess is 62.

roadrunner

coinlieutenant

I like it!!!

Catch22

I'm with Ziggy. My scanner kills luster. I do like the cleanliness of the fields and will guess that PCGS knocked it down from a 65 to a 64 for an old dipping that interupted the luster.

MFH

Yes, its a honey. I really like it too.

Grade ? I'm not a pro, but I give it a MS 64 grade. Barely a mark on it. The luster is original, but a bit dull... other wise it could have gotten a 65. Much too nice for a 61-62-or 63.

Very nice pick up.

jdimmick

I agree with mike, solid Ms-64 IMO. If not, then thier is something the picture is not giving up.

Very nice original coin.

Gemini

Hard to see the true luster of the coin in the holder for me to make a grading attempt but the surfaces do look rather nice.

mgoodm3

pretty.

Wisconsin

PCGS graded this coin a MS63. The subdued luster is the only thing holding it back I would say. It sure is a nice clean coin with nice color when tilted in the light. It's so hard to find them original looking as you all know.

ziggy29

<< <i>PCGS graded this coin a MS63. The subdued luster is the only thing holding it back I would say. >>



I think this one is an easy 65 with full luster.

eddieal

Appears to be solid 64 to me.