Dollar Coin Survivor--Round 2

jhar

With an overwelming majority the Susan B. Anthoy Dollar was eliminated in Round One. On to Round Two!! Based on the obverse design only, vote for the design you like the LEAST. In 48 hours the design with the most votes will be eliminated. I will then create a new poll with the remaining designs. We will coninue the voting until only one is left. Lets have fun Ya'll

FatMan

Sac will get sacked in round two.

JrGMan2004

Still goin with Ike to be gone...

solid

I like Ike, but think he is history!

KlectorKid

SAC this time next will be IKE.

kamehameha00

Still going with Sacagaweas, atleast SBAs look good in proof.

Shamika

No way the Sac goes down. The Trade dollar is fugly. The only thing it has going for it is history.

And that's just what it should be in "Dollar Coin Survivor"... History!

BigE

Vote for Ike, to get rid of dead presidents on coins-------BigE

mgoodm3

Sac must go.

boz

Ike

OKbustchaser

Voted Morgan round 1...voted Morgan round 2...Will probably still be voting Morgan in the finals.

JimP

Wolf359

Down with the SAC

airplanenut

Fess up... who didn't like the SBA?

jhar

ccex

I'm confessin' that I was one who voted the SBA out in round #1. If it was as hideous as the Eunice Shriver commemorative, I would have voted Ike out, which I did in round #2. If there is a round #3, I'd boot the Sac obverse (despite my admiration for the model).

I like Ike only when I can find a high grade example in a dealer's junk bin. This design is as boring and conceptually constipated as the 1950's era of his reign (sorry Lucy). I despise generals in general, and am too young to play golf. Give me Liberty (Seated, Pottying, Busty, Flowing Hair, or otherwise), but show me the death of the low relief portrait of the front man for the Cold War.

In 40 years I expect Ike dollars will still be an overlooked series collected by those who can't afford a collection of our best designs. I can now afford to collect boring Barber Dimes for exactly this reason, although I prefer the design of Mercs, Bust, and Seated Liberties.

Myqqy

Wow, close race- I agree with many that the Ike design (as just about every design with a dead white guy) is pretty weak, but what I do like about it is all of the space. With a nice proof, all of that space just looks like a mystical pool of something....

jhar

If the Sac and the Ike are this close tomorrow night, I think I will eliminate them both. If I only eliminate one, the other will certainly be eliminated next round. If both go we save some time. Whatcha think??

bearcave

You could eliminate the next 2 to save time its your game!

It's funny the SBA was the 1st to go. I have sold 2 proof type 2's for over $150 a piece in the last year. So someone likes them.

jhar

I have seen several nice looking examples of the SBA. Proofs to be exact. I know that people who do like them Like them a lot!!

MacCrimmon

IKE!!!! Yike!!

Cherwood

<< <i>Voted Morgan round 1...voted Morgan round 2...Will probably still be voting Morgan in the finals.

JimP >>



You don't like Morgans??? Shame on you!

I think the Morgan is one the prettiest coins there are.

OKbustchaser

<< <i>

<< <i>Voted Morgan round 1...voted Morgan round 2...Will probably still be voting Morgan in the finals.

JimP >>



You don't like Morgans??? Shame on you!

I think the Morgan is one the prettiest coins there are. >>



I think the reverse is great...The obverse, on the other hand, is my second least favorite design in U.S. coinage trailing only the Lincoln cent.

JimP

jhar

jhar

Last one for round 2.

mgoodm3

Ike's going down.

jhar

The votes are in and it looks like Ike is out!!

Here's the run down

Total Votes: 99


Flowing Hair 5 (votes) 5.05 (%)
Draped Bust 3 (votes) 3.03 (%)
Seated Liberty 3 (votes) 3.03 (%)
Trade 1 (votes) 1.01 (%)
Morgan 5 (votes) 5.05 (%)
Peace 1 (votes) 1.01 (%)
Eisenhower 44 (votes) 44.44 (%)
Sacagawea 31 (votes) 31.31 (%)
Liberty Head Gold 3 (votes) 3.03 (%)
Indian Princess Gold 3 (votes) 3.03 (%)

I have made an executive decision based on the number of votes that the Sac Dollar received, to "Sac" it as well. I think we can safely say that it would have gone next.

On to Round 3!!