Guess the grade of this toned Morgan**updated with grade at top**

jbsteven

Let's hear what grade you think the holder says. I gave 2 shots of the obverse at different angles so you can better judge the surface. The colors on this coin are waaaay cool.



UPDATE:

the coin came back a NGC ms66*

fivecents

Even with the hit on the reverse, I would say MS66.

Russ

MS66

Russ, NCNE

kieferscoins

MS-67.

Cameron Kiefer

CoinAddict

I will say it grades MS-66. Nice coin.

kamehameha00

A wonderful MS-65.The reverse mark destracts me too much.Still a lovely toner.


EDITED for spelling.

RiffRaff1967

How many people said "ouch" when you got to the reverse pic....?

I'm going with MS65.

Edited to add "t" to "got".

Russ

<< <i>How many people said "ouch" when you got to the reverse pic....? >>



I didn't. That's a 684 pixel wide image - just a little bigger than the coin actually is.

Russ, NCNE

Trooper

65 is mine ....nice coin

FC57Coins

MS65 - nice coin.

ElectricEye

5

Colorfulcoins

I was thinking MS66 shot MS67 till the reverse.......then probably MS66

Numismanic

MS66

nencoin

I'd say the look nudges it over the top (past the marks on the reverse): MS66

chris

CalGold

Grading a toner like this by a scan is not doable. Depending on whether the luster breaks on the face and left obverse field are only that or are marks in the surface, and whether that dark line just above Liberty's neck is a tone mark or a mark in the surface, this coin can be anything from a 63 to a market graded, got a boost from the color 65 that could just as well have been a 64 due to the reverse if white since its a common date often found in gem.

CG

mgoodm3

66 obv 65 rev, who knows how they viewed it.

gsaguy

Cool color. I'll say 65, shot 66.

What's that nasty looking discolored area to the right of the Miss Liberty's head?

GSAGUY

You should dump it. Need my address?

MrKelso

MS 66

Kriek

Definitely, MS65

Deadhorse

I'll buck the trend and say MS 64.

If I submitted it, it would come back in a body bag........

Barry

65

Tonekiller

65 shot 66

TBT

islemangu

66 all day long

rainbowroosie

64...that's if I sent it in....

gemtone65

With the marks I see, it appears to be MS64.

dizzlecc

nice, ms 66 with a star.

coynclecter

I'd go 66, the obv is real nice, would prop 67 if not for the reverse mark.


At first I thought it was the 81S in 65 you had for sale at 1950.00. I like your line "If you use the Buy It Now I will pay shipping with insurance included. "

If they pay 2000 for an 81s in 65 you should deliver it to them in Hawaii....and pay thier way there.

rkfish

65......it appears to have a bit of chatter in the obverse field
in front of Liberty and a tick or two on the cheek. Beautiful colors !!

coinkat

The fact that this coin is an 81-s is a minus. MS66 TOPS. I think the obverse is strong enough for 66 and carries the coin. My view from the cheap seats...but at least the beer is cold.

byergo

Lock 66 @PCGS, would have had a shot at 67 if not for the reverse hit. Amazing coin!

stman

<< <i>Let's hear what grade you think the holder says >>



Tough call what the holder says. It might depend on what holder (which it looks like PCGS) and also.....
Ummm how long you've had it.

jbsteven

for all who are interested. I believe the coin will end up in s ms66* NGC holder fairly soon.

stman

<< <i>for all who are interested. I believe the coin will end up in s ms66* NGC holder fairly soon. >>



That's why I said it depends on how long you've had it on grade.

Russ

<< <i>I believe the coin will end up in s ms66* NGC holder fairly soon. >>



If it does, don't crack it out and resubmit it to PCGS trying to get it back in an MS65 holder.

Russ, NCNE

jbsteven

it is still in the pictured holder (only had it a few hours). That trip to Portland might change things a little...............

jbsteven

Prometheus183

Nice toner. I'd say 65. Paying no attention to the whack on the reverse that is. Without a mag it would be barely noticable.

Craig

dizzlecc

yeah for me, I was correct in adding the star to the grade.

stman

Where is this big mark on rev everyone is talking about? Am I missing something? The darn image is blown up probably 5x the size of the coin. I get a kick outta this.

BTW, I see the hit but don't think it's soooo bad.

dragon

I would MUCH rather have that coin in that cool old 'grafitti tag' PCGS holder than any NGC holder regardless of how NGC would grade it, but then flipping it for a profit based on the upgrade wouldn't interest me either. Very attractive piece!

dragon

eisq222

MS64/65

Cam40

It could be explained to have a grade of anywhere between 63-66 or so I think by experts .
Just depends on whos selling and hows buying as to what the grade is.
Or what the meaning of `is` is.
Little Clintonian humor there. Like it?

Ok I,ll say it. For an 1881 S its not really a gem. 64 technically, maybe 5 with the nice color?
66? Sure I could see it......in an NGC holder or other lower slabs.
I dont know but I think it looks correctly graded now.Market graded that is.
Isnt a 5 in a PCGS holder as good or better than a NGC 66?
It sort of is in my book. Oh well. To each his own.

Nice Morgie.

coynclecter

I have a lot of PCGS coins in "5" , I would gladly trade for the same NGC coin in 66, and Id give you a month to find the biggest "dog" you could find to trade.

ElectricEye

<< <i>I would MUCH rather have that coin in that cool old 'grafitti tag' PCGS holder than any NGC holder regardless of how NGC would grade it >>

I agree. But then again, I am not in it for the registry points or to make a profit.

jbsteven

ttt updated

Russ

You little crackout artist, you.

Russ, NCNE

jbsteven

Russ

That is just so rude.

Russ, NCNE