How to value colonial

jhuberdude

I am submitting this to PCGS for grading. However, there are no prices for colonials listed. Do I just go by the red-book? Anyone care to guess on a grade?

numobri

I'll take a stab at the grade;

Not unc.

Looks AU,

I'll say XF 49.

Nice coin

Shamika

AU53

BillJones

I had one that was much nicer than this, which only got a PCGS AU-58. I thought that it would catch an MS-62 or 63. I'd say that this one will get an EF-45 or AU-50.

291fifth

I'll say AU50.

ConstellatioCollector

AU50 is my guess!

rainbowroosie

EF 45

Shamika

So what's the grade?

dorkkarl

it SHOULD grade vf-30, but pcgs will overgrade it to xf-45, & when you go to sell it, you'll still only get vf money for it.

K S