QUIZ: Grade this PCGS 1883-CC Silver Dollar

oreville

Take a look and offer your grade on this PCGS slabbed 1883-CC?

Also what should it buy/sell for?

Give your reasons why?

Trooper

first is it slabbed?


64
around 185 to 220
That's my guess

kieferscoins

MS-65. Put on ebay with $0.01 and let a bidding war start.

Cameron Kiefer

Stuart

MS-64 - Shot 65 -- Looks Semi-PL to PL (Hard to tell from the photo) -- Greysheet spread in MS-64 ~$185 Bid to $205 Ask

Nice Looking 83-CC Morgan. Are you considering buying or selling?

oreville

Anymore responses before I post the PCGS slab?

itsnotjustme

MS65, possibly PL.

I think what looks like chatter in front of the face may be die clash. Clearly die clash showing in the reverse to the right of the eagle's wing. Strike is too weak over ear to go higher.

davewang202

That's a 65 for a cc I believe, unless there are some hits in the lower face hidden by the angle of the lighting.

johnk

MS65PL

oreville

PCGS slab coming up.............it is a real old PCGS slab.

oreville

I paid a premium price of $237.50 for this one on ebay. I just have a feeling about this one. But It stays in this slab!

Note that there is no PCGS on the front of the insert. Also note the 4 bullet pegs on the slab.

Trooper

Woo Hoo I'm getting better at grading!!


Nice coin!!!

Tom

Stuart

Oreville: That's a quality pickup and certainly a PQ-64 that's a shot 65 (as I originally posted ) I noticed that Cameron originally posted MS-67 , but edited back down to MS-65

Well done, and well worth the purchase price!!!

oreville

Stuart: Not that i am out to defend Cameron but I did note that he did edit his his grade down to MS-65 just before I posted the answer. A close call but still counts.

The eye appeal of this coin did get me also.

I also picked up a 1884-CC in the same slab for $220. Nice as nice but with more frostiness but still was worth it for me to have a matching set. The luster seems all there but with more chatter. Not a shot 65 in my view.