Grades!! Crossed a ACG to PCGS

Lori

Crossed it over to a PCGS MS 64

This one I tried to cross. Thought it was better then the MS62 grade. Guess not. It was a DNC.



Lori

airplanenut

...even a broken clock is right twice a day! Great job with that! It shows why having a good eye (and seeing a coin in person) can make some profit

Jeremy

ksteelheader

Congrats!! Reminds me of my 49 Franklin in MS65FBL. Crossed that over fron ACG. Congrats again.....Ken

billboat

Why do you think the 1889 was DNC--AT?

billboat

OOPS! Please ignore my last post--sometimes I get SO CONFUSED! Was thinking BB.

braddick

Congratulations Lori!
Remember everyone: No one here is RANDOMLY sending ACG or PCI grades in for cross with PCGS. If so, the margin would be very narrow for success. Instead, Lori and others are pre-screening (selecting, if you will) the coins that have a shot.
The success rate should jump up with this method.

Jeremy, ACG'S clock is still broken.

FC57Coins

Congratulations Lori - you're developing quite the eye for toners and Kennedy's - just stay away from Frankies ok?

BigE

Lori, which one crossed the bottom one or the top one, I noticed the bottom one has what appears to be a PCGS label?-----------BigE

redcents

I crossed a few - 1-4 grades lower of course.

BigE

I don't understand why the bottom one would not cross as a 62-------BigE

K6AZ

If you look at my website, I actually got two Morgans to cross out of their holders at ANACS, an 87 Morgan in 64 and a 1923 Peace Dollar in 63. Those are the only two out of well over 50 that were randomly bought online (there are a lot which aren't listed on the site). In every case I am aware of an ACG coin crossing, it is a relatively inexpensive coin. For anyone who thinks ACG grading isn't so bad, buy a $200-500 Morgan in an ACG slab from ahcollectibles and see if that crosses.

mercurynut

Congrats on the cross!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BigE

So, the 89 is NOT a rare coin, still DNC, what are you saying?-BigE

Lori

The bottom picture coin did not cross (dnc). It must mean pcgs thought it was a lower grade then 62. I still dont see it. I think the coin looks like a 63/64.

The top picture crossed.

Lori

JeffinMich

BigE....that bottom coin appears to be in a SEGS (?) slab, but it's definitely not in a PCGS slab.

BigE

Good job Lori, but I think PCGS "criss-crossed" on your submission----------BigE

wingedliberty

Nicely done indeed.

Brian.

robertpr

Why do you think the 1889 was DNC--AT?
OOPS! Please ignore my last post--sometimes I get SO CONFUSED! Was thinking BB.

Bill, you were correct the first time. If a coin in another service's holder is determined to be AT or Cleaned, thumbed, whizzed, not original, a piece of crap, etc I believe it just looks to the submitter as a DNC, as they will not crack a coin out just to dump it into a BB. Though, I'm sure they've been tempted