GSA 1884-CC Silver Dollar: Submit to PCGS

tjkillian

I have an 1884-CC GSA silver dollar, without box, but still in original holder. I grade it a MS-63, maybe MS-62. Should I submit it for my free quarterly submission?

Tom

wallstreetman

No, worth more in the original holder! Wait until they start doing what NGC is doing! Now if it was a 65 then I might say go for it!

K6AZ

With the amount of GSA Morgans that have been broken out of the holders, I sure wouldn't send it in. They are commanding healthy premiums in the GSA holders.

Elcontador

Tom, if it won't go 5, save your $.

tjkillian

Thanks for all the responses. I shall leave it in its holder. The only other CC coin I have is a 1870-CC double eagle which could go MS-66.

Just kidding.

Tom

gsaguy

Why share your profit, perhaps all of it, with PCGS? Sell the coin in the original GSA holder....or better yet, keep it for your child.

GSAGUY

P.S. I typed the first line before I re-read that you're getting a freebie. Still, keep that one and send in something else.