If criticism is reasonable and handled tactfully, there's nothing wrong with it. If it's rude, uncalled for, or unconstructive, then it is worthless. How is one supposed to respond to "Your coin sucks"? That sort of comment doesn't invite discussion or even address the coin's merits.
"unjustly harsh criticism from ignorance is insulting"
and
"...As they ask in contract law, "Is it reasonable?"
If criticism is reasonable and handled tactfully, there's nothing wrong with it. If it's rude, uncalled for, or unconstructive, then it is worthless. How is one supposed to respond to "Your coin sucks"? That sort of comment doesn't invite discussion or even address the coin's merits."
I've said it before, how Shiro can have so many posts yet be as brilliant and insightful into so many of them is remarkable.
Shiro - i don't know what you do for a living but you are one very bright dude.
There are to many people using their winkies in this thread!This isn't a porno site you know. Honestly though.We all receive unwanted critisizim at one time or another but it can always be a learning exsperience.You may learn something about the coin,how people may view it or the person critisizing it.I guess it al has to do with a persons perspective of the critique.
Comments
If criticism is reasonable and handled tactfully, there's nothing wrong with it. If it's rude, uncalled for, or unconstructive, then it is worthless. How is one supposed to respond to "Your coin sucks"? That sort of comment doesn't invite discussion or even address the coin's merits.
Obscurum per obscurius
I completely agree
and
"...As they ask in contract law, "Is it reasonable?"
If criticism is reasonable and handled tactfully, there's nothing wrong with it. If it's rude, uncalled for, or unconstructive, then it is
worthless. How is one supposed to respond to "Your coin sucks"? That sort of comment doesn't invite discussion or even address
the coin's merits."
I've said it before, how Shiro can have so many posts yet be as brilliant and insightful into so many of them is remarkable.
Shiro - i don't know what you do for a living but you are one very bright dude.
adrian
That is a far cry from your opening paragraph in this thread. I'm glad to see we've changed your thinking with our powerful arguments!
Honestly though.We all receive unwanted critisizim at one time or another but it can always be a learning exsperience.You may learn something about the coin,how people may view it or the person critisizing it.I guess it al has to do with a persons perspective of the critique.