If you could put all your coins in any slab you choose!

wallstreetman

Forget about the Registries! If you had your choice of free grading for all your coins, which would you use? Only one stipulation, you have to feel confident that none submitted deserve a bodybag, I dont want you choosing a service because you think the one you really like would just bodybag some! Swallow your pride and tell the truth. Remember, the Registries dont exist! Im curious to see how these figures match with the ones you see advertized.

airplanenut

ACG of course! It's all about pride in numbers!

Dog97

PCGS

oldcameoproofsguy

I have to agree with Dog, PCGS.

KlectorKid

pcgs

FC57Coins

PCGS

goose3

For aesthetic purposely only, I like the looks of the NCS slab! PCGS is 2nd.

agentjim007

Well here's a pipe dream. I'd like to own the coins I have now, coins I bought with the safe guarding of third party grading but I want slabs to never have been invented. I wish I could hold my coins in my hands (properly of course). I'd like to view them without the glare of the plastic. I want to be intimate with my coins, I feel like I'm visiting someone in prison. Someone is going to tell me to crack them out but slabs are here and I have to play by their rules and they need to be in slabs (PCGS).

EVillageProwler

Can I have a mix? I collect mostly classical silver coinage, and I prefer toning. The white cores of the NGC slabs go well with toned silvers.

For my white coins, and even gold, I prefer the old black cores. In their absence, I prefer PCGS. I find the clear plastic holders from ICG and SEGS to be too translucent for my liking.

EVP

Russ

The newest grading service, PGS.

Russ, NCNE

rkfish

PCGS!

dorkkarl

anacs, because of their ability to attribute varieties.

K S

Steve27

GSA, the only coins I trust to be unaltered are found in slabs from the government.

FrattLaw

Moderns - PCGS
Toned - NGC
Error - ANACS

Michael

MW Fattorosi Collection

flaminio

Honestly? It doesn't exist. I have some problems with all the grading services. Picking any one of them involves compromises. Maybe I need to start my own slabbing service....

prooflike

I'd go with PCGS for my Morgans and NGC for my type set, kindda like I am doing now!

Twowood

(1) PCGS
(2) NGC
...Six of one,half dozen of the other. I see little difference. Twowood

kieferscoins

PCGS.

Cameron Kiefer

tradedollarnut

Hey - let's make it more interesting:

Which grading service would you choose if you HAD TO LIVE BY THE FIRST GRADE ASSIGNED? That's right, no cracking it out and resubmitting it? You have to keep it in the original holder and when it comes time to sell, you have to sell it in that holder as well.

jcping

PCGS

mr1931S

Which grading service would you choose if you HAD TO LIVE BY THE FIRST GRADE ASSIGNED? That's right, no cracking it out and resubmitting it? You have to keep it in the original holder and when it comes time to sell, you have to sell it in that holder as well.

PCGS still.They are the most consistent graders and have the most attractive holder...

Does anyone know how one can find out WHEN a coin was encapsulated by PCGS?
Is there a database available somewhere to search to find this out by entering the number of the coin?

mr1931S

I just wanted to add that PCGS could/should do more to attribute varieties...