Should a July 4th privy Quarter be added to a type set

WALLE

What is your thinking about the July 4th quarter being added to a type set collection, or just adding any or all of the 2026 quarters would be enough.

MsMorrisine

strictly speaking, i'd think it's a variety and not a real type

Morgan13

I would think that its part of a type set.
If you dont have it you will be missing a coin that was minted in 2026.
Be patient though. The price will come down.

jmlanzaf

Could be either. If you treat it like a mint mark, which privy marks are similar to, it's really more of a variety. If you consider it a design element, it's a type.

MasonG

Call it an 09-S VDB and your set is complete.

jmlanzaf

@Morgan13 said:
I would think that its part of a type set.
If you dont have it you will be missing a coin that was minted in 2026.
Be patient though. The price will come down.

That would make it part of the year set. I think it's more ambiguous whether it represents a distinct type. There is a non-privy quarter, so you wouldn't be missing a 2026 quarter.

TwoSides2aCoin

Only if the individual collector chooses to . But only 250,000 of those will have one. How many holes in an album or folder will remain empty forever ?

CaptHenway

In my opinion, no.

jmlanzaf

@MasonG said:
Call it an 09-S VDB and your set is complete.

Lol. Or replace it with a Sunoco token

MasonG

@jmlanzaf said:

@MasonG said:
Call it an 09-S VDB and your set is complete.

Lol. Or replace it with a Sunoco token

Then you'd have a complete set of Shell tokens.

TomB

What is your take on the State quarter series and all the other series that came after them? Should they all be included in type sets? If not, then you have your answer. If so, you might still have questions.

The_Dinosaur_Man

For a type set, it should be considered the same type as the other quarters issued this year, all of which would be confined to a single spot in that set.

Now for a year, mint, and "finish" set, it's an absolute must.

oldabeintx

I’m not planning to include it as the motivation behind it bothers me - it’s more gimmick than design element. Once it’s cheap enough I may weaken tho. We’ll see.

jmlanzaf

@TomB said:
What is your take on the State quarter series and all the other series that came after them? Should they all be included in type sets? If not, then you have your answer. If so, you might still have questions.

I think that's an interesting question. I think it is easier to consider the state quarters as different types than the privy. After all, they each have a different design. Yet, a 21st century type set would likely only include one of each series.

All commemorative halves are considered to be a single type in type sets.

Regardless, a privy is even a less dramatic difference.

Russell12

@oldabeintx said:
I’m not planning to include it as the motivation behind it bothers me - it’s more gimmick than design element. Once it’s cheap enough I may weaken tho. We’ll see.

Aren't the State Quarters, America The Beautiful Quarters, American Women Quarters, Presidential Dollars, Innovation Dollars all gimmicks?

WALLE

I'm going to add it to my 250th anniversary album (I'm still working on it) being i think it fits better there.

jmlanzaf

@Russell12 said:

@oldabeintx said:
I’m not planning to include it as the motivation behind it bothers me - it’s more gimmick than design element. Once it’s cheap enough I may weaken tho. We’ll see.

Aren't the State Quarters, America The Beautiful Quarters, American Women Quarters, Presidential Dollars, Innovation Dollars all gimmicks?

No

Is your position that no quarters have been issued in 27 years?

oldabeintx

@Russell12 said:

@oldabeintx said:
I’m not planning to include it as the motivation behind it bothers me - it’s more gimmick than design element. Once it’s cheap enough I may weaken tho. We’ll see.

Aren't the State Quarters, America The Beautiful Quarters, American Women Quarters, Presidential Dollars, Innovation Dollars all gimmicks?

I suppose a case could be made, but I like the educational element of the various series. I know I’ve learned something from them. The 7/4/76 quarter is more like the added privies, an obvious gimmick.

oldabeintx

Limiting production is a major clue.

Coins3675

I wouldn't add it as a required coin, but I am personally adding one