~Guess The Grade Roulette~

Aspie_Rocco

60

Coinscratch

AU53

pcgsregistrycollector

@Coinscratch said:
AU53

Nope

pcgsregistrycollector

@Aspie_Rocco said:
60

Nope

Clackamas1

That is an original roll coin. They get that surface being in the paper that long. I only see a hit of the face and I don't have my glasses. 65

Coinbert

AU 50

dcarr

I see some wear on the high points. I would be inclined to guess AU50, although it could also be a really nice EF45. Since "50" is already taken, I will guess EF45.

jfriedm56

AU58

Coinscratch

And me thinks the light is low and could be hiding the MS but like Dcarr says lot of wear of the high points so I'm inclined to guess the same but with the proper prefix. XF45.

marcmoish

61

pcgsregistrycollector

@jfriedm56 said:
AU58

Correct. I will post a slab shot later but, you are up

jfriedm56

Thanks @pcgsregistrycollector. How about this one.

Coinscratch

MS66RD

Clackamas1

66RB That is one heck of a hard date in Gem RD.

Aspie_Rocco

64RB

pcgsregistrycollector

@Clackamas1 said:
66RB That is one heck of a hard date in Gem RD.

Agreed. I seen this one before. Very nice pickup @jfriedm56.

pcgsregistrycollector

Also, here are the slab shots for the last coin.

dcarr

MS65RB

JeffersonFrog

65BN

jfriedm56

Sorry so late to respond. You are correct @Clackamas1. You’re up.

Clackamas1

jfriedm56

MS65 Full Steps

Coinscratch

MS64FS

pcgsregistrycollector

Is this the one u cherry-picked? Looks like a 64 fs

Aspie_Rocco

65 (not full steps, nicks/hits, rounded bottom right) nice strike though!

JeffersonFrog

66FS

Rc5280

MS66

Coinscratch

@Aspie_Rocco said:
65 (not full steps, nicks/hits, rounded bottom right) nice strike though!

They didn’t mention the subjective grading when it comes to the difficult years. Full steps from CoinFacts.

alaura22

I know what it is because I cheated..........................but won't say it to keep it going

marcmoish

65+

Aspie_Rocco

Beautiful coins @Coinscratch but none are true full steps. I often see the full step designation on coins like you posted, and deeply sigh with disappointment every time. Every time.
It misleads collectors who do not know better, into paying exorbitant amounts for coins that are misrepresented as something they are not. Full Strike would be a more appropriate and honest designation.

Clackamas1

@jfriedm56 said:
MS65 Full Steps

Right out of the gate. You are up.

Clackamas1

@Aspie_Rocco said:
Beautiful coins @Coinscratch but none are true full steps. I often see the full step designation on coins like you posted, and deeply sigh with disappointment every time. Every time.
It misleads collectors who do not know better, into paying exorbitant amounts for coins that are misrepresented as something they are not. Full Strike would be a more appropriate and honest designation.

One of those is mine and it is Full steps. the 68-D. It is hard to see from the photo but it is there.

Aspie_Rocco

@Clackamas1
I love the look of that 68 D. Stunning color and I would be proud to own it in any grade, my 68 D is very plain looking.

jfriedm56

Here’s the next one.

Rc5280

65

Aspie_Rocco

MS66

Clackamas1

64

dcarr

MS63

jfriedm56

@Rc5280, correct! You’re up.

Rc5280

Thanks @jfriedm56
Thanks for patience everyone.

Right-click/new tab - it's a fairly high res image, and may come in handy! GTG...

Clackamas1

67

Coinscratch

MS65+

jfriedm56

MS66+ Nice double clash marks on the reverse.

Aspie_Rocco

@Rc5280 said:
Thanks @jfriedm56
Thanks for patience everyone.

Right-click/new tab - it's a fairly high res image, and may come in handy! GTG...

Vam 6b?
http://ec2-18-216-53-178.us-east-2.compute.amazonaws.com/wiki/1886-P_VAM-6B

Rc5280

Not yet,

Good catch on the VAM @Aspie_Rocco , care to GTG?

Copperindian

MS66

Rc5280

Nope

JeffersonFrog

67+

dcarr

MS65*