Is this a joke?

eyesopen

Found this in a Loomis roll today. Has to be a magicians coin or something. Both sides are obverse design the only difference is one has a P mint mark and one has a D mint mark. Not possible to be an error. The weight is 5.3 oz. How and why


would someone make this?

FredWeinberg

The “P“ side was the original reverse
It was hollowed out and a cut down “P’ (corrected)
Obv. Was inserted you can see the seam just inside the rim.

pcgs69

when you drop it, it should make a thud sound rather than the traditional ping that a quarter makes.

knovak1976

Shake it in a glass and see if it separates. If so, it’s a magician’s coin. Usually we use a device called a ‘bang ring’ to separate trick coins that nest inside each other.

eyesopen

Thank you. I was perplexed when I found it in the roll. Will be a fun one to play heads or tails with

Smudge

Weight is 5.3 oz?

jesbroken

I have one somewhere, haven't seen it in a while. I would imagine 5.3 oz would be right as some metal removal would occur. Have no way of estimating how much.
Jim

hummingbird_coins

@FredWeinberg said:
The “P“ side was the original reverse
It was hollowed out and a cut down “D“
Obv. Was inserted you can see the seam just inside the rim.

I think the "D" side was the hollowed out one.

davewesen

Just think of how many times you could win flips +++
I am sure a previous owner is upset they lost that one.

Smudge

@jesbroken said:
I have one somewhere, haven't seen it in a while. I would imagine 5.3 oz would be right as some metal removal would occur. Have no way of estimating how much.
Jim

Hockey puck coins weigh 5oz.

Catbert

Welcome to the board! Glad you're here.

As a courtesy to others, when making threads please include what your question and/or topic is about in your thread headline so that readers have the option to decide if they wish to open your thread and make a contribution.

FredWeinberg

Yes, I should’ve said cut down P mint

jesbroken

Got me, meant grams. Duh! Lol Follow the leader.
Jim

bsshog40

I forgot where I got mine from , but here's mine.

WAYNEAS

No need for "heads I win, tails you lose.
Great find.
Wayne

ebaybuyer2

i have a half dollar i "discovered" when the coin star repeatedly rejected it, i looked at it closer and noticed it had the dual date obverse but the traditional eagle reverse. at first i thought it was counterfeit, then realized it was a magician piece. gets the blood churning for a minute or two

JBK

Just to clarify, there are magician's coins, which are usually meant to open and the insert flipped over to reveal a different coin.

Then there are novelty two-headed or two-tailed coins. They don't open.

eyesopen

Thank you all for your kind comments. I will make sure to preface the question in my subject line. Thank you also for correcting my oz vs grams. I have much to learn.

Steven59

I think Amazon sells them - fun find!