Home U.S. Coin Forum

Which would you choose

I have the option to inherit one of these coins. 1914 S 5 Dollar Indian or 1925 20 Dollar St. What would your choice be? I am thinking the 1914 S.


Tagged:

Comments

  • Thank you Smudge. I have only started collecting the last few years. Can they be removed from the mountings? The Indian was never worn. My mother wore the St for a few years and then forgot she had it. I appreciate any comments.

  • HillbillyCollectorHillbillyCollector Posts: 390 ✭✭✭✭

    @eyesopen said:
    Thank you Smudge. I have only started collecting the last few years. Can they be removed from the mountings? The Indian was never worn. My mother wore the St for a few years and then forgot she had it. I appreciate any comments.

    Can be removed but will leave rim marks.
    Go for that DE, as was mentioned.

  • johnny010johnny010 Posts: 869 ✭✭✭✭✭

    $20

  • telephoto1telephoto1 Posts: 4,633 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited June 27, 2023 10:53AM

    The $20 is the one to pick. The bezel is easily removed by taking out the tiny screw at the top. Use an eyeglass screwdriver or small jeweler's screwdriver. it shouldn't have damaged the coin as it goes around the coin rather than the type that has four retaining prongs, which can dig into the coin.
    Edit to add location of screw:


    RIP Mom- 1932-2012
  • Dave99BDave99B Posts: 8,239 ✭✭✭✭✭

    $20

    Dave

    Always looking for original, better date VF20-VF35 Barber quarters and halves, and a quality beer.
  • WalkerfanWalkerfan Posts: 8,664 ✭✭✭✭✭

    The Saint

    “I may not believe in myself but I believe in what I’m doing” ~Jimmy Page~

    My Full Walker Registry Set:

    https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/

  • percybpercyb Posts: 3,265 ✭✭✭

    $5 since I already have the other.

    "Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world." PBShelley
  • Downtown1974Downtown1974 Posts: 6,587 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Exactly what Smudge said.

  • johnny9434johnny9434 Posts: 27,008 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Take the big one

  • OwnerofawheatiehordeOwnerofawheatiehorde Posts: 1,193 ✭✭✭✭✭

    If the $5 doesn’t have scratches and is UNC, it would be worth more than the DE. If it is damaged, go with the DE.

    Type collector, mainly into Seated. Young Numismatist.

  • tommy44tommy44 Posts: 2,157 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @telephoto1 said:
    The $20 is the one to pick. The bezel is easily removed by taking out the tiny screw at the top. Use an eyeglass screwdriver or small jeweler's screwdriver. it shouldn't have damaged the coin as it goes around the coin rather than the type that has four retaining prongs, which can dig into the coin.
    Edit to add location of screw:

    I agree with what telephoto1 said.

    It's also possible the the bezel in 14K vs gold filled. If 14K lots more gold here than in the bezel on the $5. The bezel on the $5 looks like your typical gold filled "Cowan's" type bezel where the one on the $20 looks special.

    it's crackers to slip a rozzer the dropsy in snide

  • gumby1234gumby1234 Posts: 5,170 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I had one of the St Gaudens size bezels years ago it was solid gold.

    Successful BST with ad4400, Kccoin, lablover, pointfivezero, koynekwest, jwitten, coin22lover, HalfDimeDude, erwindoc, jyzskowsi, COINS MAKE CENTS, AlanSki, BryceM

  • coinbufcoinbuf Posts: 10,395 ✭✭✭✭✭

    No question for me, take the $20.

    My Lincoln Registry
    My Collection of Old Holders

    Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.
  • ChangeInHistoryChangeInHistory Posts: 2,970 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited July 2, 2023 2:03AM

    Go on, take the twenty and run.

    Sincerely,
    Billy Joe & Bobby Sue

  • TrampTramp Posts: 614 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @coinbuf said:
    No question for me, take the $20.

    ^^^^^

    What they said!
    .
    +1
    .

    USAF (Ret.) 1985 - 2005. E-4B Aircraft Maintenance Crew Chief and Contracting Officer.
    My current Registry sets:
    ✓ Everyman Mint State Carson City Morgan Dollars (1878 – 1893)
    ✓ Everyman Mint State Lincoln Cents (1909 – 1958)
    ✓ Morgan Dollar GSA Hoard (1879 – 1891)

  • Namvet69Namvet69 Posts: 8,388 ✭✭✭✭✭

    But what's behind door number 3?

    BST: endeavor1967, synchr, kliao, Outhaul, Donttellthewife, U1Chicago, ajaan, mCarney1173, SurfinHi, MWallace, Sandman70gt, Ricko, mustanggt, Pittstate03, Lazybones, Walkerguy21D, coinandcurrency242 , thebigeng, Collectorcoins, JimTyler, USMarine6, Elkevvo, Coll3ctor, Yorkshireman, CUKevin, ranshdow, Jzyskowski1, CoinHunter4, bennybravo, Centsearcher, braddick, Windycity, ZoidMeister, mirabela, JJM, RichURich

  • JimnightJimnight Posts: 10,592 ✭✭✭✭✭

    The double eagle.

  • PerryHallPerryHall Posts: 44,839 ✭✭✭✭✭

    The double eagle has been lightly polished but it's still almost a full ounce of gold. That's a nice rope bezel that's probably 14K gold. Check it for any markings near the clasp. If it were mine, I'd just leave the Saint in the bezel and sell it as a nice jewelry piece.

    Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.

  • lkeneficlkenefic Posts: 7,476 ✭✭✭✭✭

    If given the option, the $20 DE every time! They're both ex- jewelry so I'd defer to bullion value... theres much more gold in the $20...

    Collecting: Dansco 7070; Middle Date Large Cents (VF-AU); Box of 20;

    Successful BST transactions with: SilverEagles92; Ahrensdad; Smitty; GregHansen; Lablade; Mercury10c; copperflopper; whatsup; KISHU1; scrapman1077, crispy, canadanz, smallchange, robkool, Mission16, ranshdow, ibzman350, Fallguy, Collectorcoins, SurfinxHI, jwitten, Walkerguy21D, dsessom.
  • Both settings are full 14K gold. If both coins were not mounted as jewelry. Would your opinions be the same? Which coin is more collectable on its own?

  • SmudgeSmudge Posts: 9,057 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Neither is rare. It boils down to would you rather have an ounce of gold or a quarter ounce. If you just love the Indian design, sell the Saint and buy a nice certified Indian.

  • MetroDMetroD Posts: 1,869 ✭✭✭✭✭

    1914-S $5 Indian - PCGS #8529
    1925 $20 St. Gaudens - PCGS #9180

    From the PCGS 'Price Guide':

    The lines intersect at x = MS-60 (i.e., y = $2,500). Based on these 'reference/ask' prices, the better financial choice is currently the $5 Indian only if it is MS-61, or higher.

  • Thank you Metro D. That information is what I was looking for. Not the gold value. Thank you all for your input.

  • lkeneficlkenefic Posts: 7,476 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I doubt either of those would straight grade at 61... but stranger things, I suppose...

    Collecting: Dansco 7070; Middle Date Large Cents (VF-AU); Box of 20;

    Successful BST transactions with: SilverEagles92; Ahrensdad; Smitty; GregHansen; Lablade; Mercury10c; copperflopper; whatsup; KISHU1; scrapman1077, crispy, canadanz, smallchange, robkool, Mission16, ranshdow, ibzman350, Fallguy, Collectorcoins, SurfinxHI, jwitten, Walkerguy21D, dsessom.
  • airplanenutairplanenut Posts: 21,756 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited June 30, 2023 3:02PM

    @eyesopen said:
    Thank you Metro D. That information is what I was looking for. Not the gold value. Thank you all for your input.

    Except with the coin being mounted, it's likely both damaged and at least a bit circulated. It may have more numismatic value than a ho-hum dated Saint with the same potential issues, but the latter coin has a lot more gold and thus still a higher value. Unless you have a sentimental reason to keep one of the coins, you can always sell the Saint and get a nicer $5 Indian of a common date (with plenty of money to spare) or throw in a few hundred bucks and walk away with a nice, uncirculated Saint.

    JK Coin Photography - eBay Consignments | High Quality Photos | LOW Prices | 20% of Consignment Proceeds Go to Pancreatic Cancer Research
  • rickoricko Posts: 98,724 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I would choose the $20 Saint.... Then sell it as jewelry (unless it is a family heirloom) and buy a really nice Indian. Cheers, RickO

  • matt_dacmatt_dac Posts: 954 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Silly question….but what a nice problem to have.

    Ounce of gold or a quarter ounce? Neither have numismatic value.

  • OwnerofawheatiehordeOwnerofawheatiehorde Posts: 1,193 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @matt_dac said:
    Silly question….but what a nice problem to have.

    Ounce of gold or a quarter ounce? Neither have numismatic value.

    Well, the problem arises as the $5 does have numismatic value, and is more valuable than the Saint as long as its MS. (Which I doubt)

    Type collector, mainly into Seated. Young Numismatist.

  • Che_GrapesChe_Grapes Posts: 1,764 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Since you’re inheriting it I would say chose the one you like the best, regardless of value.

  • Elcontador1Elcontador1 Posts: 93 ✭✭✭

    Have someone who knows $5 IHC, grade the coin and get an opinion re whether it is in fact Unc. and will grade after removal from the mounting. The 14 S is a better date in higher grades. I inherited a circulated one from my grandmother.

  • PerryHallPerryHall Posts: 44,839 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Based on the pics in the first post, the 1914-S is not even close to being mint state. You would be lucky to get an AU50 straight grade and more likely you would get a XF45 grade with the possibility of a cleaned designation. Even in its polished/cleaned state, the double eagle is far more valuable.

    Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file