GTG - Roosevelt Dime NGC Crackouts - - REVEALED!
ProofCollection
Posts: 6,121 ✭✭✭✭✭
I have another data point in the ongoing NGC vs PCGS discussion.
I picked up 3 cheap NGC dime slabs, cracked them out, submitted to PCGS, and I have the results. I'll divulge those later on below. I admit there could be selection bias here. The slabs were probably cheap for a reason so you can probably see where this is headed.
If you want to have some fun, GTGs before I post them...
Tagged:
1
Comments
63, 65FB, 64
Mr_Spud
64, 65, 65
65, 66FT,66FT edit FB for PCGS
Successful BST with ad4400, Kccoin, lablover, pointfivezero, koynekwest, jwitten, coin22lover, HalfDimeDude, erwindoc, jyzskowsi, COINS MAKE CENTS, AlanSki, BryceM
MS66, MS65FB, MS64FB.
Coin Photographer.
Interesting. I'll still wait a few hours to post the PCGS grades. Here are the NGC grades:
Anyone surprised?
WOW. Those are lofty grades.
Pete
What are the PCGS grades?
OK I guess it's time to reveal the PCGS grades:
1954-D MS66
1992-P MS66FB
1998-D MS65FB
I don’t know a out the clads but the 54 looked FB to me, more so than the 92
Are they what you thought. Not sure I’d crack out the proof like
Martin
I got them cheap so I don't care too much about the results financially but I'm disappointed. I expected 66FB on all 3. Disappointed about not getting FB on all of them. Hard for me to believe PCGS and NGC can't agree on the that at least. I expected to lose the PL designation. The 98 doesn't look 65 to me but I'm not the best at grading these.
Well... Late to the game...(a lot of that lately)....but would have guessed the PCGS grades in the reverse - 65, 66, 66. Cheers, RickO
Back to the "cheap slab" box?
Also late to the game, but I was 65, 66, 65, all FB.
Tom
How much value did you lose by sending them to pcgs?