Options
Guess the grade
Rockdogz
Posts: 145 ✭✭✭
I know it's kind of dumb because it's a modern, but there's a reason I'm asking...care to guess?
It came back as a PR60DCAM! ouch
0
Rockdogz
Posts: 145 ✭✭✭
Rockdogz
Posts: 145 ✭✭✭
Comments
These types of photos won’t show anything in the fields, but based on how you worded the post and the nick above the V in FIVE, I’ll guess it’s graded 70 but shouldn’t be.
@airplanenut "the nick above the V in FIVE, I’ll guess it’s graded 70 but shouldn’t be."
Exactly what I was thinking.
I'll go out on a limb. Hard to tell with the odd shape of the coin but maybe there is some cabinet friction near the stitching and a little nick above the edge of both lower stitching? I'll go 66.
PF69 would be my guess. I have never seen this particular coin before.
PROOF 69DCAM
PR70 DCAM. I'm definitely not an expert, just my wild guess since it seems to be flawless.
USAF (Ret.) 1985 - 2005. E-4B Aircraft Maintenance Crew Chief and Contracting Officer.
My current Registry sets:
✓ Everyman Mint State Carson City Morgan Dollars (1878 – 1893)
✓ Everyman Mint State Lincoln Cents (1909 – 1958)
✓ Morgan Dollar GSA Hoard (1878 – 1891)
69 DCAM
RIP Mom- 1932-2012
PR69DCAM
It came back as a PR60DCAM. I didn't even know that grade was possible...
Agree with the PR69DCAM
I suppose it could also be a SP69 DCAM
I have one of these coins - mine is silver, this one looks good but I think it’s silver too.
Where’s that guy at who always says “is this a mechanical error”?
I had a similar experience where pcgs graded one of my proof platinum eagles proof60dcam. I called them up hoping the person accidentally put a 6 instead of a 7 on the grade. They “fixed” the grade by regrading it a 69DCAM. Not what I was hoping for.
Up to you if you want them to reholder it as a 69, or leave it as a 60. Worth about the same.
Well, looks like a 66 is $550 and a 69 is $635...not that it matters right now since I'm not selling it. I was just really surprised...should have it back in hand later today to see.
And after getting the coin in hand, I really don't see anything wrong with it...I'm no grader by any means but I would think that whatever was responsible for a 60 should be fairly obvious
I don’t see anything that would lead me to believe it’s anything less than a 70.
Very nice👌
Can you post the cert number so we can see the full size true view?
Cert #46122483
@Rockdogz... Looks to me as if it should be PR69. Contact customer service. The mark above the V in five likely knocked it down from 70. Cheers, RickO
Thanks. Def not PR60. I would contact customer service as ricko suggested and/or send it in for reconsideration. A PR60 should look trashed. This coin is easily 68-69, 67 on a bad day.
PF69DCAM.
60 must be a typo. Looks like a typical PF69
Funny, as I was typing this, I went for the nine and accidentally hit zero that’s probably exactly what happened.
My YouTube Channel
I would have left it as it was. Pop 1
Lol…I was hoping to check the price guide and see my one and only PR60 but alas I think - like others have said - it was probably an error, either PR70 or PR69. I will contact customer support, thanks!
Customer service responded that the grade was correct…???
I would do a guarantee resubmission. https://www.pcgs.com/servicesandfees
You pay $25 but when they re-evaluate it if they messed up you don't pay anything.
They definitely messed up. I am sure it was supposed to be PR69. BUT, at this point, it's a Pop 1 coin!
Wow on the 60DCAM score.
No wait, make that "NO WAY!!"
That means nothing unfortunately. CS has been trained to say no, no, no whether asked for refunds/rebates due to poor/slow service or grading issues. To them, you are just another person complaining about a bad grade result and, unless you make a stink or come out of pocket ahead of time, the grade is ALWAYS correct. MEs only exist for date, mm, etc.
Also, the 'nick' above the V is not there on the coin in hand. It must be an artifact of the photo.
Well officially pop 1 of 1...showing up on the pop report now
