Indeed, it is. Which is why I gave everyone a video 😉
@DeplorableDan said:
I see no reason to drag this out, a lot of you nailed it. The coin is fresh ms65 from our hosts. I am told from the seller that the coin was actually cracked out of an NGC 67 holder and resubmitted to pcgs. I have no idea why the owner would do that, when an NGC brown line Wells Fargo 67 sells for substantially more than double what I paid for it. Next, I’ll be submitting this to CAC and I think it has a good shot at a bean. Thoughts? Here’s a link to my instagram reel, let me know if this link works for someone without an instagram account
@VanHalen said:
Those who call it a 64; What do you see? Do you think something like luster, strike or color bring it down?
Inquiring minds want to know.
Mushy weak strike, along with yellow magic marker streaked toning.
I’d have that coin back at NGC so fast trying to attain that 67 grade again, and sell it
I think it’s highly unlikely that the strike or the color on that coin would cause graders to penalize the grade.
I agree with the first half of Mark Feld’s comment. I would never have crossed it out of NGC MS-67 to PCGS MS-65 slab either. I would have also tried to get NGC to regrade it as MS-67 as well as quickly as possible. But evaluating a coin’s grade based on photos only is tough especially when supersized. All imperfections are magnified.
Comments
Indeed, it is. Which is why I gave everyone a video 😉
Founder- Peak Rarities
Website
Instagram
Facebook
That's a great pickup and nice looking coin!
I agree with the first half of Mark Feld’s comment. I would never have crossed it out of NGC MS-67 to PCGS MS-65 slab either. I would have also tried to get NGC to regrade it as MS-67 as well as quickly as possible. But evaluating a coin’s grade based on photos only is tough especially when supersized. All imperfections are magnified.