1907-S Barber Quarter P01?

OAKSTAR

Assuming for a minute she would qualify for a P01, would these hits disqualify she? A couple of hit on the edge pushed the metal up on the rim. Would something like this market acceptable?

TomB

I don't believe that coin would straight grade.

291fifth

It belongs in the melt bucket, not in a slab.

JWP

It has a kinda like blank stare.

ricko

I believe that coin has passed the point of no return. Cheers, RickO

LanceNewmanOCC

which image is most accurate to the height of the meal on the obv. the 1st or 2nd image? if the 1st, should be fine, the second, a bit risky. there are PLENTY of P01 barber dimes, halves and quarters in buckets/tubs/bags etc, one can be choosy.

i'm curious just how strong the S is that a TPG would agree.

Dave99B

I also feel this won’t straight grade. Rim dings at a minimum eliminate this one IMO.

Dave

OAKSTAR

@LanceNewmanOCC said:
which image is most accurate to the height of the meal on the obv. the 1st or 2nd image? if the 1st, should be fine, the second, a bit risky. there are PLENTY of P01 barber dimes, halves and quarters in buckets/tubs/bags etc, one can be choosy.

i'm curious just how strong the S is that a TPG would agree.

Can you restate or clarify your question again for me?

LanceNewmanOCC

@OAKSTAR said:

@LanceNewmanOCC said:
which image is most accurate to the height of the meal on the obv. the 1st or 2nd image? if the 1st, should be fine, the second, a bit risky. there are PLENTY of P01 barber dimes, halves and quarters in buckets/tubs/bags etc, one can be choosy.

i'm curious just how strong the S is that a TPG would agree.

Can you restate or clarify your question again for me?

is there enough of the mm still visible that the TPG would agree.

that is to delineate just how many times, we the submitters, see things the TPGs do not agree with. hehe

edited to add: not that we the submitters are always wrong as sometimes the TPGs simply don't want something too risky in their holders, especially as time marches on.

OAKSTAR

Well yes, not the best but the MM is there if the coin is in-hand.

LanceNewmanOCC

@OAKSTAR said:
Well yes, not the best but the MM is there if the coin is in-hand.

ok. trying to save ya a few bucks as in my experience, if pcgs (tpgs) have to work to figure something out w/o the coin being a high-tier and/or extra paid service, you'll get the coin back other than anticipated. make sure those dates/mm and/or undeniable features are more than good enough. some slip through, most don't.

OAKSTAR

@LanceNewmanOCC said:

@OAKSTAR said:
Well yes, not the best but the MM is there if the coin is in-hand.

ok. trying to save ya a few bucks as in my experience, if pcgs (tpgs) have to work to figure something out w/o the coin being a high-tier and/or extra paid service, you'll get the coin back other than anticipated. make sure those dates/mm and/or undeniable features are more than good enough. some slip thorough, most don't.

Will do. Thanks for that. 👍🏻