Options
If both cards were the same money ...which one would you buy?
ScoobyDoo2
Posts: 839 ✭✭✭✭✭
If both cards were the same money ...which one would you buy?
This is a public poll: others will see what you voted for.
2
ScoobyDoo2
Posts: 839 ✭✭✭✭✭
Comments
The top one looks like a 4. The bottom looks like a 6.
all 4 corners of the PSA 4 look much better than the PSA 6..... and the centering of the PSA 4 is on another planet....
In reality~ the asking prices on ebay currently are ~ PSA 6~ $9,599.99~ PSA 4 ~ $2,299.00.... both are overpriced for the grade.
That 6 might qualify as the worst 6 ever, Remember buy the card not the holder.
The PSA 4 is the newer grading standard and is just as the nice as the PSA 6.
The 4 all day here
This grading example is embarrassing .... in truth..the more I evaluate these two examples.... if I am honest. I cannot hang my hat on any positives for the PSA 6 ...NONE.
Unless there's something horrendous going on the back of the card, the PSA 4 looks way nicer to me. Nicer eye appeal, new label, everything.
Both then I would sell the 6.
Great 4 but the stain on the right is the reason I think.
That 6 is just silly. That is a 2.
Grab the 4 and run to the hills...
whoever graded that top card a six needs to be fired. no way that is a six the corners are awful.
something funky must be happening on the back of the 4
George Brett, Roger Clemens and Tommy Brady.
I've seen worse ~ back of the PSA 4
IT's remarkable the disparity in grading on older serial numbers... its a different standard to be sure. If you got high grades early on in the system you are grandfathered in...lol.
The 4 is better centered, slightly faded, but I would go with the 4 unless there is a crease or impression(s) that cannot be seen in these pictures.
Absolutely!!!
Live long, and prosper.
A perfect example of how grading standards have become stricter w/time...
The 4, by 1200 country miles
Absolutely!!!
Live long, and prosper.