How close do you think the grades are for these two toned Peace $'s?

gtstang

No cheating if you already saw them previously.

ChangeInHistory

I'll guess 65 and 64

Floridafacelifter

I like the blue one!

DelawareDoons

I consigned the blue one lol.

Gotta be honest, can't believe it straight graded. And yes, it looks like that in hand.

FlyingAl

I'll go 65 and 63+.

jayPem

I think they have a wheel they spin when coins like these hit the grading room..
2,3,4,5 ED, QC
Just spin and grade

Edit to add that I like them both a helluva lot 😘

alaura22

Like them both
66
65

cameonut2011

Regardless of what the slab says:

UNC DETAILS- QC
UNC DETAILS- ED

Crypto

Gen QC
64

jerseycat101

Both are AT in my eyes.

ricko

I grade them 'Not in my collection - and would never be.'.... Seriously, the first one looks AT, the second had a bad experience. Cheers, RickO

TPRC

Bottom one looks NT. Not sure on the top one, but I'll say NT also. They both look pretty clean. So, I'll say 65 and 64

ChrisH821

I would definitely have expected QC on the first coin. Neither are my cup of tea.
I'll guess the bottom one is a 65.

gtstang

Glad @DelawareDoons got a good sale on his and I def agree on the questionable look but it is straight graded.
They are very far apart in grade per pcgs.

conrad99

What explains the weird shape of the curve?
Shouldn't it be an arc?

DelawareDoons

@gtstang said:
Glad @DelawareDoons got a good sale on his and I def agree on the questionable look but it is straight graded.
They are very far apart in grade per pcgs.

For whatever it's worth, I didn't grade that Peace. I bought it off eBay for $55 as a BIN.

gtstang

@DelawareDoons Pretty decent ROI for that one. I thought it was interesting on how close fellow commenters thought the grades were for these two.

@conrad99 toning can really be any shape or randomness depending on how it was stored and what was around or on the coin.

braddick

I like the AU coin the best.
I wonder if it is closer in appearance to the TrueView or the Great Collections photo?

DelawareDoons

@braddick said:
I like the AU coin the best.
I wonder if it is closer in appearance to the TrueView or the Great Collections photo?

Found the pic I took of it after I got it.

braddick

Sweet coin.
The price on GC accurately reflects the 'value' of this Peace dollar IMHO.
Your purchase price was a steal.

DelawareDoons

@braddick said:
Sweet coin.
The price on GC accurately reflects the 'value' of this Peace dollar IMHO.
Your purchase price was a steal.

Well, as is, sure. But I think it's a details coin all day, and I'm flabbergasted by the fact it's in a straight-grade holder. My best to the new owner, though.