SSCA $50 Kellogg gold slug broken collar error by Dwight Manley and Ron Landis
Zoins
Posts: 34,117 ✭✭✭✭✭
Here's a fascinating broken collar error from the 2001 SSCA transfer die restrikes of the 1855 Kellogg $50 gold slugs. It has a finned rim and was struck with a broken collar. It was struck on August 25, 2001.
These were created by Dwight Manley using transfer dies prepared by Ron Landis.
Anyone know the story about the broken collar and what happened?
Hopefully @Dwight_M can fill us in 
Tagged:
5
Comments
Super duper cool!
.
CoinsAreFun Toned Silver Eagle Proof Album
.
Gallery Mint Museum, Ron Landis& Joe Rust, The beginnings of the Golden Dollar
.
More CoinsAreFun Pictorials NGC
Interesting... Have not seen that effect before.... I hope someone chimes in with process detail. Cheers, RickO
Here is another one that Kagin’s sold in 2017. Don’t know how many are out there…
Very interesting Mike @Byers! Here's the one from Kagin's:
https://www.icollector.com/1855-August-29-2001-California-Historical-Society-Commemorative-Restrike-Kellogg-Co-50-Gold_i27907219
I originally thought this was unique as mentioned by Kagin's, but in looking into this more, I want to say I've seen one more *that haven't been able to locate it just now). So, I'm guessing at least 3 right now.
A nice thing about these is the date struck counterstamp. The one from Stack's in the OP was struck on August 25 while the one you posted from Kagin's was struck on August 29.
It would be great if PCGS had different coin numbers for error types, like variety coin numbers.
If we find any other specimens, let's post them in this thread!
This one is on EBay for about 20k right now, it’s an AUG 25th… it’s the same one from your OP.
I used a picture as the link was a mile long.
It's all about what the people want...
Here's the TrueView and slab photos of the August 29 specimen from Kagin's:
That is super cool!!! I placed an order to Dan Carr for a 1934 $20 Sain Gaudens fantasy strike but he sold out and my check was misplaced. MR. Carr offered to strike one more coin or he had a multiple strike piece he would give me instead. I took the multiple strike coin and is is a fantastic triple struck coin.
Wow, nice! Congrats! You scored big time!
The problem with coins coming from private mints is that you don't know if an error is a legitimate error or was an intentional error.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
I fixed it for you
We have lots of discussions on US Mint product so we shouldn’t ignore that.
For private issues, we do know for some based on discussions and manufacturing process. This needs to be better documented and we do need more info on others like the Kellogg pieces here.
I will say that the more common something is, the more likely it will an intentional error. And the more likely something will be to damage the press, the more likely it will be an unintentional error.
Regarding the pieces here, what are the chances that two collars broke within 4 days of each other? Perhaps the first one was unintentional and the subsequent ones were intentional?
I would guess the triple struck 1934 Saint was intentional. However it is a great looking coin especially due to the large size of the coin.
Disregarding the value, I'd much rather have a perfectly struck example. The coin is made-up to begin with, so you might as well get a nice one.