Grade this 1915 buffalo nickel

BUFFNIXX

Grade this 1915 buffalo nickel

hummingbird_coins

MS65

MsMorrisine

Pr66??

hummingbird_coins

oh... I hadn't thought about proof grades

hummingbird_coins

Proof-65?

koynekwest

Nice black eye.

AMRC

65

Smudge

PR66

amwldcoin

LOL!

Black.Diamond

MS65

kaz

@koynekwest said:
Nice black eye.

Us Tareyton smokers.....
MS65?

koynekwest

That's goin' WAY back!

mannie gray

I don't like the coin with the crud and prints.
63 money, maybe. If I was in a good mood.

BUFFNIXX

To me that black “eyepatch” is quite a distraction. The other spots not so much.

ricko

I would guess 65... but if mine, would see if that black crud could be removed....Cheers, RickO

1Bufffan

It does have the die crack on the reverse over the shoulder as on proofs so I'd say Pf 65 finger print may have developed after it was encapsulated same with "Blackeye" still a nice coin.

keets

PF65, dipped and starting to retone.

BuffaloIronTail

Was gonna say PF63, but thought about it.

PF64 (Dipped - Like Keets said).

Pete

ChrisH821

Tough one. I assume it is a proof, I'll go 65.

clarkbar04

PF66

BUFFNIXX

It looks like the Indian lost out in a fist fight.

BUFFNIXX

Here is the slab and without the eye spot it would probably be a 65 IMO
thanks to all who participated in this thread and as to it being proof as opposed to uncirculated
the arcing die crack across is a good indicator of it being a proof never have seen a 1915 buff
with this die crack on a business strike and if I were grading both sides this would be PR 63/66
reverse is really nice by itself