New 41-S Walker for my short set! What do you think? GTG (answer down below)
d9lowe
Posts: 312 ✭✭✭✭
This is one of my favorite Walkers yet in my almost complete MS Walker short set. How did I do? GTG
5
Comments
Softly struck but I like softly struck S mint walkers. Looks like an MS-63. But an awesome MS-63. Reverse looks nicer. Very clean unblemished walker for the grade.
Very likeable coin indeed.
Bottom of obverse looks like planchet was struck from what appears to be rusted die in that area but does not detract.
On the other hand, I find it charming.
Nice Walker. Looks pretty clean of marks. Typical weak strike. I'll go 64+
64
Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value. Zero. Voltaire. Ebay coinbowlllc
Clean coin. Weak strike is typical. I’ll say 65.
nice coin... tough call. I am thinking 65 and 65+ would not surprise.
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
I prefer better struck examples but that one has a ton of luster.
probably about as good a strike as you are likely to see for the issue. Looks really clean except for a reed mark between solar rays. I'll venture MS65
I like it. My guess is MS65.
You have good head detail and the hint of the branch in Liberty's hand. The right field looks very clean as well. Not sure about the noise near the sun's vertical ray. Shame your reverse photo is out of focus, as it is not possible to see how the eagle's feathers are struck up. Photos suggest excellent luster.
65.
65 easy.
Great luster, clean fields, typical San Fran strike - MS65 (maybe even a 65+)
"When they can't find anything wrong with you, they create it!"
For any other date, a bad strike
For a 41S, nice strike
BHNC #203
65
I believe that there are other dates, for which that would be a nice strike.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Agreed, the '42S & 43S come to mind.
BHNC #203
@dlmtorts
@coinkat
@Allentram
@kaz
@JBN
@clarkbar04
@Steven59
@ThreeCentSilverFL
Good job guys!!
Its a MS65 CAC
Thanks for the insight. I like doing these to get other opinions and see what other people catch and i learn from that
64
Well... Late to the game, but 65 is a good grade for that WLH.... Very nice coin. Cheers, RickO
Pretty!
It is clear I blew the grade as I was not thinking about the usual soft strike for the 41-S.
Upon a second look I would easily agree with Ms-64 or even MS-64+ CAC but having a little trouble going to MS-65 CAC. Photos can be hard on our eyes to evaluate. the grade.
Regardless of grade it is a likeable coin.